TPMDC
« Coleman Camp Gets Caught Not Sharing Evidence With Franken Side, Coaching Witness | Home | Minnesota Judges Strike Key Coleman Witness, After Failure To Share Evidence »

Boehner: GOP Policies Are Politically Harder, Dems Offer Free Lunch

The Wall St. Journal reports that John Boehner made an interesting observation about the Republican Party's problems: It's simply harder to sell their own ideas to the public, compared to the easy answers offered by the Democrats.

"We have a tougher job than our friends across the aisle. They've been offering Americans a free lunch for the last 80 years, rather successfully," Boehner said, at a lunch hosted by the Christian Science Monitor. "Those of us that believe in a smaller, more accountable government, we have a tougher time making our principles relevant to the American people. But it's our challenge, and we've got to do it."

A note about free lunches and small government: Boehner voted in 2003 for the Medicare drug bill, a mega-expensive expansion of entitlement spending with no method laid out on how to pay for it. And the modern GOP's platform is based largely on tax cuts, with the constant claim that they'll result in even more revenue.


60 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Yeah, bonehead. The republicans have only been offering a small slice of the top 1% of americans and corporate america a free lunch, and more. Gotta love that 2003 welfare handout to big pharma. Brilliant. Or how about all the welfare shoveled to haliburton for the king and darth vader's retirement plans. Or how about the welfare handouts to the financial industry. Or how about the welfare handouts to military contractors. Or, or, the list is endless. I guess it's all a matter of perspective and marketing. What a bonehead.

user-pic

People have caught onto the R's "big government is the problem" mantra and figured out that it's not big government to be feared, but Republican-style government. Once people realize that the emperor has no clothes, it's tough to convince them again that he does.

user-pic

Not to pick too much of a nit, but republican-style government (that is, with a small R) is what we originally fought the British for. It simply means representative government protected and maintained by a constitution. Although you used a big "R", you still might avoid that particular phrase, lest the flying monkey get hold of it and use it as a talking point. Say GOP-style government instead.

user-pic

I hope you are right. I thought that after the b-movie actor's crap and it still took another 20 years.

Speaking of the b-movie actor, I wish the stupid pundits would not insult obama by claiming that he is "reaganesque." The b-movie actor was a profligate liar and charlatan. Obama is neither. It's like comparing bozo the clown to einstien. No comparison, obviously.

user-pic

By the way, now that I think about it, I just insulted bozo the clown by associating him with the b-movie actor. I apologize to bozo the clown. Sorry.

user-pic

yeah well, Bonzo was the brains behind that act...

user-pic

It's a gift, that ability to utter enormous lies in such a brazen manner, without a hint of unease. If the guy had anything even approaching charisma he'd be terribly dangerous.

user-pic

Did you just describe Sarah Palin?

user-pic

Uttering enormous lies in a brazen manner is not a gift. It's GOP policy. They have practiced it and have it fine tuned to a fault.

user-pic

The GOP needs Governors giving these messages not politicians with a paper trail that contradicts the claim they are trying to make. Any Republican who was in the House or Senate under the Bush Administration has any ground to stand on. They should look to primary out any Senators who are in safe Red seats, get new blood and new voices not stained by their complicity to the Bush years.

Just don't pick Jindal (who chooses the person to give the rebuttal - was Jindal set-up to fail? A political hit of sorts by a connected rival).

user-pic

Boner admits to failing at his job and especially the last 8 years! his new tactic...he's trying honesty.

user-pic

> They've been offering Americans a free lunch
> for the last 80 years, rather successfully,"
> Boehner said, at a lunch hosted by the
> Christian Science Monitor.

That is awesome. Was he eating pork at the time?

user-pic

It's simply harder to sell their own ideas to the public

...well, yes, but only because they've already been tried and didn't work...

compared to the easy answers offered by the Democrats

Wait, "spend trillions of the public's dollars" is an "easy answer"? Funny, I've never thought of that as a particularly easy sell.

user-pic

Boehner-nomics baby!

user-pic

Welcome to the Boehn-Zone!

user-pic

Huh? This is a party that believes cutting taxes solves all the world's problems -- from depressed government revenues to budget surpluses to declining Sunday school attendance to the massive breakout of teenage acne. You can't get much more free lunch than saying cutting taxes raises revenue or fry them criminals.

For years, Republicans have appealed to our caveman instincts. They don't even need to speak in complete sentences: Government, bad. Tax cuts, good. Terrorists, evil. Military, good. Pull out 'ol sparky. It can't hurt.

Come on, Johnny.

user-pic

"Let them eat cake" has never been a popular political slogan. Hard to sell it to people who might have access to a guillotine...

user-pic

Yeah, that's it, blame the American people. It's the same twisted logic that led Cheney's hunting buddy to apologize for getting in the way of Cheney's shotgun blast. Duh?

user-pic

"It's simply harder to sell their own ideas to the public"

That's because they're at least 10 years past their shelf life.

user-pic

The modern Republican party was founded on the ultimate free lunch. Reagan in 1980: Raise defense spending, cut taxes and balance the budget.

If you're bidding for votes, it's hard to top that.

user-pic

You know he's right, Republicans have never offered a free lunch to the American people.

Well, except for that whole bit about fighting two wars while simutaneously cutting taxes...

user-pic

Did I mention I cain't spel?

s-i-m-u-l-t-a-n-e-o-u-s-l-y

user-pic

...and just exactly how has Republican government been accountable?

user-pic

the repubs are done. period. it's a regional party. the south has finally been defeated.

user-pic

Republicans say things like this, and it always make me wonder: does it really never occur to them that the reason Americans aren't "buying" their ideas is because they're bad ideas? Or do they know that, but they are simply lying?

I go back and forth on it all the time. Perfidy or incompetence seems to be the only two choices for their behavior, and certainly neither option is good in a bunch of people who (supposedly) want to run the government.

user-pic

Haven't you heard? The problem is not that they're bad ideas. They just haven't marketed them well enough.

Republican#1: How come these shit sandwiches aren't selling?

Republican#2: We need a new slogan! Or maybe we should go hip-hop.

user-pic

I'm pretty sure Jason Jones posed this same Shit Sandwich Conundrum to a GOP strategist on The Daily Show about a month ago. Her suggestion on how to move them: "Dip it in chocolate and label it 'Low Fat.'" Mmmmm -- eat up, America!

user-pic

There is a third option. Perfidy and incompetence are not mutually exclusive.

user-pic

It's the old "are they lying, or are they really that stupid?" question.

As Steve points out, the answer is "YES!".

user-pic

Republicans have ideas? Stop the press.


Another creep. Palin/Jindal/Steele/Cantor/Boehnr

It's a party of creeps.


user-pic

You forgot Limbaugh and Santelli.

user-pic

There is no such thing as a "free lunch," tax cuts cost too. I guess, Boehner doesn't remember the big tax cuts, accompanied by soaring deficits during the Reagan administration.

user-pic

How about the big tax cuts and the roaring deficit increases of the past 8 years?

user-pic

Let's not forget the 12 to 17 percent home mortage loan interest rates during the "Reagan" era. I remember because I thought at the time, "I'll never be able to afford a home."

Ronald Reagan, a fraud and intellectual lightweight, despised working-class and middle-class Americans. He led a dismantling of unions. He sold illegal arms to Iran.

Fastforward: Lest we forget: George W. began his administration (which he stole from Al Gore) with a $128 billion SURPLUS. The republicans are fiscally responsible? I would be laughing if it wasn't so devastating and traumatic for our country right now. Their policies shifted the greatest amount of wealth in history into the pockets of the few. And, Cheney/Bush's thinly-veiled attempt to capture Iraqi oil failed. They have the blood of tens of thousands on their hands. Dare I say it? Far more deaths from this illegal war than 9/11. We talk about the 4,000+ American soliders--THAT exceeds 9/11--how about the 50,000 or 60,000 DEAD IRAQIS? How about DEAD allies? How about the tens of thousands disabled and destroyed in this ILLEGAL war?

Thank you, Republicans, for bringing us your own homegrown greedy DISASTER!

user-pic

Call the wahmbulance and cart his ugly mug to nearest tanning salon.

user-pic

One of the leaders of a party that offered tax cuts during one war, and anotherwar that would pay for itself is accusing dems of offering a 'free lunch' to the American people?

user-pic

Who is offering a free lunch?! That's rich. The Boehnerhead's party spent most of the last 8 years deficit spending like drunken sailors, and offered five course bonanzas of tax breaks to the richest of the rich.

What shit-for-brains and his GOP don't seem to get is that it's over, America is on to their bullshit. Jindal's half-assed attempt last night was almost pitiable, if it wasn't such a great thing for America that the current GOP is exploding into a thousand pieces.

user-pic

Well, here's a suggestion: start of by conceding that lunches exist, and stop obstructing the preparation of any kind of non-breakfast/non-supper type meal, then move on to the cost/benefit analysis... just a suggestion

user-pic

Maybe Boner should offer people free tickets at his favorite tanning booth.

user-pic

Republicans offered us free tickets to the whorehouse without a condom in our pockets. It felt nice for a night, rest is history.

I'm talking about "taxcuts."

user-pic

No, Senator Bonehead, it is very hard to sell the american people your CORPORATE policies, which is all you have. They are not GOP ideas, they are CORPORATE. Since Corporate is anti-thetical and openly hostile to PEOPLE policy, it IS a very hard sell.

If corporations had ever put humanity and the earth first, maybe people would have a different view. As it is, Corporations/GOP have tried their best to clothe their corporate policies with some semblance of redneck, man-on-the-street mumbo jumbo; but finally, at last, that has worn thru.

Now the American People can see clearly what your ideas represent, and most of the smart ones are pulling their arms away from your arsenic drip.

user-pic

I see they've decided to martyr themselves. See, only they have the answers, and they're hard answers for we mere mortals to understand. Way to patronize the American public. It also seems somewhat Calvinistic...as if their so called "hard" way must inherently be better.

user-pic

I realize that I'm not particularly bright, but unpaid for tax cuts seem like free breakfast, lunch, and dinner to me...with dessert and drinks thrown in as well.

user-pic

For the past few decades, I've thought that as a society one of the biggest problems we seem to be suffering from is the refusal to take any responsibility for personal and collective actions.

If your child does poorly in school, it's the teachers fault. If you get a traffic ticket, it's the cop's fault. If you spill hot coffee on yourself because you were trying to drive and drink at the same time, it's the restaurant's fault and they should pay you for your suffering.

On the collective level, we spent and spent and spent and delayed action on infrastructure, education, health care..the list goes on.

And now, the GOP leaders are insisting that it's not their fault that Americans don't get their message. Obama is too charismatic. The Republicans need more bling to make their message resonate. And now comes my favorite: of course the American people hate us--Democrats will give them anything they want.

The problem the Republicans have right now is that they haven't figured out that we're weary of skirting our responsibilities. We've been waiting for a way out of the wilderness. And finally, we've got a leader who calls on us to think again about more than ourselves and to delay our gratification so that we can actual solve some of our larger problems.

They don't have any plans of their own because they been the party of blame for thirty years. They think it's everybody's fault but theirs, and frankly, I hope they keep thinking that all the way to total and complete irrelevancy.

user-pic

Excellent post. Incidentally, it reminds me of why everyone I know who is 70, plus and with a brain thinks that obama sounds just like kennedy. He was the last one to address the points in your post and asked americans to be responsible. "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country." Sound familiar. Since then all we've gotten was happy talk bullsh*t and irresponsibility. Obama really is like kennedy. Amazing.

user-pic

Yes Orlando. Reality is a bitch.

user-pic

Right on. But I believe there is some real blame to go on the ReFoolAgins that has never belonged to the Dems.

ReFoolAgins continually pushed policies which were anti-people, anti-earth, anti-fair. Dems continually did the opposite. ReFoolAgins were wildly successful, as the Corporate Party....skillfully using huge corporate money and organization and sneakiness. No other gathering of "people" parties could ever match their funds, their juice, their pull, their organization and positioning. Really, plumbers unite! Teachers against Huge International Corporations!

There is a point where the ball was never in the avg. americans hands anymore....the whole system has been wrenched out of our hands and been going the wrong way for at least 30 years. Somehow, someway, we have temp. got ourselves back in charge....I hope. But the system is still grievously rigged and riddled with Corporate corruption.

We as a whole are stronger than even these Corporate Titans, and we do bear some responsibility. However, it required our most supreme effort to gain control even for an instant, while Corporate Corruption ran smoothly for 30+ years on cruise control...and it will slip back to them just as easily without supreme vigilance and courage. I hope enough of the populace has had their eyes opened.

user-pic

Have these boneheads even considered the fact thay can't "sell" their ideas is because they are so outdated phony?

They had no problem pushing the product the last 30 years.

Such bull$hit for the biggest shoveler.. ugh my bloodpressure goes up just thinking about these idiot.

user-pic

If the choice is between "free lunch" and "starving" what do you think people will choose?

user-pic

So if Republicans are having a hard time selling their ideas because Americans prefer a free lunch, doesn't that confirm America is not, in fact, a center-right country whose citizens detest entitlements and Big Government?

Republican stalwarts seem not to have awakened to the realization that shouting "entitlements" and "Big Government" no longer calls forth images of teaming urban ghettos. Not for most Americans, anyway, and certainly not now that so many are scared out of their minds about their jobs, their houses and their health care.

These guys are frozen in amber clinging to an idealized version of Ronald Reagan. I was 20 when Reagan took office. I'll turn 50 next year. These guys need to get over it and move on.

user-pic

Unfortunately for Republicans, their behavior running the government during the Bush years has made their claim of being the party of fiscal responsibility utterly hollow.

user-pic

Tax cuts and no are not ideas.

user-pic

I think TPM used the wrong headline for this. Your headline should be: "Boehner Thinks the American People Want a Free Lunch."

That's the striking and politically important, even explosive, aspect of his statement. He's suggesting that the America people are looking for the easy way out, and not willing to do what's hard. We can debate the veracity of that perspective (and likely conclude it's severely misguided), but that doesn't mitigate the ramifications of Boehner, a leader of the Republican Party, intimating that Americans are lazy and want handouts.

I think this statement confirms that if anyone is lazy here, it's the Republicans. They simply aren't willing to put in the intellectual lifting necessary to make themselves appealing to the American people. [HINT: Suggesting that voters are lazy won't help your cause.]

user-pic

I agree. Bonehead should go to his grave with this quote tattooed onto his magnificently tanned forehead. This should be hung around his neck for the rest of his un-natural life.

user-pic

Boehners Taxcut Elixir - Combats Liberal Leanings, Guarantees Victory, Will Make You Rich, Smokes out Terrorists, Balances the Budget, Grows back hair, Good for Cleaning Guns

Who will be the first to buy a bottle?

user-pic

Exactly NCD, you've just about said it all. Just about the way they say it too.

user-pic

So now it's time to crank up the culture war to make the good folks in the base forget that they vote against their better interests.

user-pic

"Those of us that believe in a smaller, more accountable government, we have a tougher time making our principles relevant to the American people"

So, who was in charge of the American government for most of the last 8 years, and the US Congress, for most of the last 15 years? They had their control. They had their chance. Look at the result. The problem is not their inability to deliver their message to the American people. The problem is the American people got the message and disapprove of it.

user-pic

Great comment. Finally Americans got the message! And the message is this: "I got mine; f*uck you!"

user-pic

The reason it's hard to sell GOP ideas to Americans is that most Americans just don't have that kind of money.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address