TPMDC
« Poll: Vitter Below 50% For 2010 -- In Both Primary And General Elections | Home | Franken Has Good Day, Potentially Netting Over 30 Votes »

Can You Filibuster a Budget Bill? And Other Pressing Questions

Quite a few readers have written in recent days with questions about the Republicans' ability to filibuster the $410 billion spending bill that's currently on the Senate floor, which is expected to come to a final vote late tonight or tomorrow morning.

Can you filibuster this spending bill? Yes -- because it's not a budget resolution, which is a non-binding document that sets general revenue levels for the next fiscal year. The $410 billion measure is what congressional types call "omnibus appropriations," meaning that it sets overall spending levels for various governmental departments from now until October, when the 2010 fiscal year begins.

So when you read about Mary Landrieu (LA), Ben Nelson (NE), and other Democratic centrist senators who are bridling at the high spending levels in President Obama's budget, it's important to remember that they're referring to the non-binding, filibuster-proof document that will likely come to a vote by mid-April.

Democrats can afford to lose as many as eight of their own senators on that vote, while still passing a budget with 50 votes and Vice President Joe Biden as the tie-breaker. The party can also use "budget reconciliation" rules that would allow for filibuster-proof passage of health care, climate change, or even student loan bills later in the year, provided that such legislation achieve a demonstrable reduction in the deficit.

The total savings can be small; for instance, last year the Democrats used reconciliation to pass a student-loan bill that saved $75 million, which is small potatoes compared with the overall budget but achieved meaningful reform for anyone attending college. No decision on reconciliation has been made yet, but it's safe to say that the debate is heating up.


10 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

MORE LIKE THIS.

user-pic

It should be filibustered until the administration provides accurate cost data. The student loan proposal alone will add $1 trillion to the national debt!

user-pic

Thank you, ma'am.

user-pic

What's the basis for that prediction?

user-pic

Actually, there is no factual basis for ustate05's prediction. Student loans have an historical rate of return of nearly $5 on the dollar to the federal treasury in income taxes due to the increased earnings of those who obtain higher education with the assistance of federally guaranteed student loans.

The above aside, the "conversion" of $75 million to $1 trillion should clue anyone that ustate05 does not know of what they speak.

user-pic

A trillion dollars in debt for the student loan program alone?

Just what are you smoking?

What kind of evolutionary process is acting upon Republicans whereby more and more outrageous claims that have less and less basis in reality are accepted more readily by a larger percentage of their party members?

Here's a hint: the party is losing all the smart people.

user-pic

"Deficits don't matter. Reagan proved that ..." - Penis Cheney 2004.

user-pic

So when you read about Mary Landrieu (LA), Ben Nelson (NE), and other Democratic centrist senators who are bridling at the high spending levels in President Obama's budget, it's important to remember that they're referring to the non-binding, filibuster-proof document that will likely come to a vote by mid-April.

And that they're happy to vote for their states' earmarks in the omnibus bill.

user-pic

So Obama's budget can't be filibusterd hmmm. Guess most of it should end up in tact.

user-pic

Reagan did this with his 1981 budget. Let's see if anyone in the Lamestream Media remembers. And let's see if any of the GOP in either house who voted for Reagan's tactic in 1981 now decry this.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Elana
Schor

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address