TPMDC
« Minnesota Trial Wraps Up -- But The Spin Keeps Going | Home | TPMDC Saturday Roundup »

GOP Rep Submits Bill To Require Birth Certificates From Prez Candidates

Rep. Bill Posey, a freshman Republican from Florida, is now putting forward a bill that should be good news for a particular demographic that cares a whole lot about their issue: Those folks out there who insist that President Obama hasn't offered a birth certificate to prove he's a natural-born U.S. citizen.

CNN reports that Posey has submitted a bill to require all presidential candidates to submit a birth certificate -- which Posey says is needed in order to remove this issue as a reason to question any president's legitimacy.

"Opponents of President Bush used the 2000 election results and the court decisions to question the legitimacy of President Bush to serve as President," Posey said in a statement. "Opponents of President Obama are raising the birth certificate issue as a means of questioning his eligibility to serve as president. Neither of these situations are healthy for our Republic."

Posey's spokesperson told CNN that Posey takes President Obama's word for it that he's a citizen: "This was not meant as an insult to the president. It is simply meant as a way to clarify future election laws and to dispel the issue so we can move on with doing business for the country."

A quick check of the Library of Congress' Thomas site shows the bill does not have any cosponsors yet. But Posey only introduced it on Thursday, so he's just getting started.


172 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Why is it that the first president whose citizenship is questioned is also the first African American President? When will the MSM just spit it out and call this bile the racism that it is?

user-pic

Bingo.

user-pic

Double bingo.

What really is telling is that the candidate who had an issue concerning citizenship and ability to be president was the old white guy. He wasn't born in the US. What did dems do? They didn't question it at all and passed a bill in the senate to declare no opposition and that there was no issue.

Now, you have an african american born in hawaii and they question it? Somebody else pointed out that nothing could be done to satisfy these racist loons. I actually find it telling that obama released his birth certificate immediately, which he didn't have to do and that still wasn't enough. They could have video from the delivery and 100's of witnesses come out and say that this is absurd and they still would claim that there is an issue. It really is a sad statement on the republican party and its supporters. I guess that they are living in a pre-civil war fantasy land where birth certificates weren't issued for african-americans. Pathetic and racist.

user-pic

3. Florida (January 10, 1861)

...lest we forget, Florida was the third state to secede from the union because Lincoln was elected.


user-pic

Double bingo on this comment, as well.

user-pic

"The South's gonna rise again?"

Anyone born south of the Mason Dixon line still harboring stale loyalties and Civil War era prejudices might well be accused of having been born in a foreign country?

The Confederate States of America, maybe?

Gosh, that would sure shorten the list of southern-born Presidents. No Clinton, no LBJ, no Carter, no Bush(s). The Dems would certainly take the biggest hit, but considering Bush(s) is on that list, it makes up for the others.

user-pic

It is not the Civil War to those folks. It is the "War of Northern Aggression"

The same folks behind this (wing nut daily) are the people who were hounding Bill Clinton his entire term about Vince Foster. They will not give up, and if they lose on the birth case they will move on to the Indonesian citzenship case, then move on to whatever the hell else. They will not give up, they will never be satisfied.

user-pic

"the people who were hounding Bill Clinton"

Mellon Scaiffe as their principal financier?

It's possible...

user-pic

Richard Mellon Scaife has since made nice with the Clintons. He made a sizable -- approx. $1 million, if I recall correctly -- donation to the Clinton Foundation/Library/Global Initiative, took Ms. Hillary to lunch during the campaign and his PA vanity newspaper endorsed her warmly.

Strange bedfellows....

user-pic

Actually, I was suggesting Mellon-Scaiffe might well be behind the NEW crop of naysayers who are dissing Obama...

Or at least in that same country club...

user-pic

Scaife put Joe Farah on the map, and his WingNutDaily is the ones primarily responsible for pimping out this story.

user-pic

Not so strange opportunist!

user-pic

So, to review, let me get this straight:

* The Democrats hurt our Republic, by questioning the election of 2000 in the courts. This, of course, is why it was called "BUSH v. Gore".

* Republicans would never be so crass and opportunistic as to try to negate the results of an election, via oily "trial lawyer" methods. See also: the complete works of Eric Kleefield [g].

* Rep. Posey isn't offering this bill to hurt or "insult" the President. No, quite the contrary, he's protecting the President from unscrupulous mad political types, who might try to impugn the legitimacy of this fine fine man, by seeing to it that all "questions" about his legitimacy are safely out of the way. Unscrupulous mad political types like... um... who could he be referring-to?...

I sincerely hope nobody clues the Republicans into the fact that, the more they treat the people like their own hard-core "base" (i.e., drooling, ignorant idiots), the more they're marginalizing themselves with normal Americans. No, really, don't tell them!

(That having been said: FreeRider alert, below! :-)

user-pic

Triple bingo. Birth announcements were published with all the relevant details in Hawaii in August, 1961.

http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/obamabirth.php

Surely this plot to have an Indonesian qualify at birth to be president is the most elaborate ever conceived. You gotta hand it to Barack's single mom...she planned ahead.

user-pic

You gotta hand it to Barack's single mom...she planned ahead.

LOL707LOL707!!!

user-pic

Wonder if she had a handy-dandy time machine?

user-pic

Thanks for the link and info. This really is despicable.

user-pic

It's not really despicable. It's comic.

user-pic

more like 'comically despicable.'

user-pic

Neither of those announcements indicate where BHO was born. They only include the supposed address of his parents.

If anyone wants the actual facts about this matter - what we know and what we don't know, no speculation - see this extensive discussion:

http://24ahead.com/s/obama-citizenship

In order to avoid wasting my time, please see this earlier thread at this site where I responded to common misconceptions about this issue:

http://peekURL.com/zkywrus

user-pic

His mother was a citizen so where he's born is moot.

You go around to all the sites posting this BS. It's totally lame.

user-pic

The argument over what we know about where he was born is definitely not "moot" since it shows that many MSM hacks, FactCheck, Snopes, et al are willing to lie through their teeth. As I point out at the link, there's no definitive proof of where he was born. I also provide a challenge at the link: call Hawaii and get them to confirm what FactCheck pretends they said on 10/31. No one has taken up that challenge, despite how easy I've made it by including the phone number, the person to speak to, and the questions that could clear all this up.

And, that's a separate issue from the natural-born issue.

user-pic

His mother is a US citizen so it doesn't matter where he was born. He's a naturalized citizen.

But . . .

The "certificate of live birth" states he was born in Honolulu. The State of Hawaii says that the "certificate of live birth" is the birth certificate. The State of Hawaii verifies that Obama's is legit.

But that's just gravy because it doesn't matter if he was born on the back of a stage coach in the middle of Dubai since his mother is a US citizen.

user-pic

FreeRider, could you please stop lying?

The state of HI has never verified the picture of a COLB that appears on BHO's site. The fact that that picture says he was born in HI means nothing until it's been verified by the issuing agency. And, they haven't verified it.

All they've said is that they have a valid cert on file. They didn't confirm that what they have on file matches the picture on BHO's site.

user-pic

'Splain something: why would the state of Hawaii have Obama's original birth certificate if he wasn't born there?

'Splain something else: The document Obama has released has a raised seal, is dated June, 2007 and signed by Alvin T. Onaka. If this is all fake, why doesn't the State of Hawaii call Obama out as a forgerer?

'Splain something else: Why risk faking a birth certificate when it doesn't matter where you were born since your mother was a US Citizen?

user-pic

FreeRider: what is the *legal* and *procedural* meaning of "original" *in this context? AFAIK, his original cert could indicate a foreign birth and he could still have a valid HI birth certificate. "How is that possible?", the intellectually honest reader asks. Because under HI law, even those born outside HI can get valid certs depending on the residency of their parents. And, that law was clearly meant to apply to those born before 1982, since it referred to those living in the "Territory" of HI, an entity that was dissolved two years before BHO was born.

As for the picture on BHO's site, it would be illegal for HI to verify it. If it's fake and they haven't called him out, perhaps it's because they're supporters. I seem to recall a recent case of an OH official losing her job because she did something she shouldn't have, and something like that could be happening in this case.

The bottom line is that we just don't know what's going on here because BHO has not been forthright. Obviously, there's *something* he's hiding, whether related to his cert or his college records or similar.

user-pic

Oh, go away you dumb fuck. You are pathetic. Go play at redstate.com. The earth is flat too you know. There is no picture of the entire earth at one time. I'm telling you it's flat.

user-pic

You people alleged that the picture posted on the site is different from all the other birth certificates issued to Hawaii born citizens. The folks from Hawaii says its identical to what everyone else receives.

Of course, they can't say *definitively* without examining it in person. Just like you can't call it a fake from a picture!

user-pic

Guess what? The President of the United States is a Black Man. Sorry that offends your sensibilities.

user-pic

Oh, and the State of Hawaii did indeed verify that the document presented by Obama is authentic.

"It's a valid Hawaii state birth certificate," spokesman Janice Okubo told Politifact.

user-pic

On the very same page, she says: "I don't know that it's possible for us to even say beyond a doubt what the image on the site represents."

user-pic

Question: Why would they go through this elaborate ruse to fake a birth certificate since it doesn't matter where he was born?

His mother is a US citizen.

I just love watching you wingers go down the rabbit hole with this idiocy. It's so much fun to watch you become more and more fringe and to destroy the republican party chasing ridiculous conspiracy theories.

user-pic

Lonewacko (if that really is your name... oh wait, it might be...), you are making me defend Freeper, well-known jabone. May you burn in Hell, for that alone.

Here's the BIG question, Wack: WHAT'S YOUR END GAME, HERE?

No, really. Let's say you somehow ram this bill through a heavily Dem Congress. Let's say it goes to the WH, and President Obama, in a spirit of bipartisanship, signs it into law. Let's say, on the basis of this new law, a "bipartisan committee" appoints Kenneth Starr special prosecutor, and Obama is impeached for not having the proper credentials, bloodlines (skin color?) to be President.

Let's say we all stop dropping acid now.

Would I be paranoid in saying that this is naught but a continuation of the old-school Gingrichian playbook: trot-out a "Democrat controversy" every three weeks...Whitewater, Paula Jones, travelgate? In the case of President Obama, we could... oh, I dunno... eat up the airwaves, talking about Michele Obama's arms; Obama's "biting off more than he can chew"... and just keep smacking him with something new, continually, until the public wears down and says, "Oy... not that damned Obama, again???

You are aware, aren't you, that WE are aware, that a GOP mucky recently bragged that their whole m.o. will be to "drive up Obama's negatives"? Got that? He bragged about doing exactly what we're watching happen here!

Like Nancy Pelosi just said: when you lose the policy argument, you fight it on procedure; when you lose the procedural fight, you attack the personality. Not that it's working or anything, but that's only because any movie can spawn just so many sequels, before the public just walks the hell away and says "fuck it". Take the hint.

user-pic

Proof those sites are lying?

user-pic

"In order to avoid wasting my time..."

Too late. You've wasted quite enough already.

user-pic

Carl Sagan said "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof." Instead of putting the onus on Obama to prove he was born here (despite a birth certificate, verification by REPUBLICAN health department officials & a birth announcement in the local paper) WHY DON'T YOU OFFER A SINGLE SHRED OF PROOF THAT HE WASN'T? You claim he was born in Kenya? Show me a Kenyan birth certificate. His mom traveled to Kenya to secretly give birth and then sneaks back in to this country? Show me a passport or Visa stamp. He is the duly sworn President of the United States. Got a problem with that? Then vote in 2012! Quit trying to de-legitimize his Presidency. You just sound like a kook and a sore loser!

user-pic

VanArsdale:

Links - and logic - are your friends. I'm not claiming that BHO was born here, there, or the other place. My claim is that no definitive proof of where he was born has been offered. If you don't understand the difference, find a smart friend to explain it to you.

user-pic

The earth is flat too. There is no definite proof that it is round. It's flat I tell you.

user-pic

Your argument, Wackytobacky, follows the exact line of logic of Republican hack/asshole Ben Ginsburg, and his rationale for throwing out the entire MN election.

After the MN election boards and courts meticulously followed every facet of MN law, to determine what existing ballots were eligible, which ones must be discarded, etc., the Coleman team succeeded in proving only ONE thing: that any election or recount can only be theoretically perfect. Ginsburg et.al. are saying that if a contest cannot be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt to be beyond that... absolutely perfect... the entire contest must be thrown out. Therefore, if any court of law determined that an election contest exhibited 99.9% accuracy, it would have to be thrown out and, according to Ginsburg's argument, you then would have to invalidate every election for dogcatcher in America on the same grounds.

Your argument, as I say, is identical to this bullshit. You're using the old, rugged "We may never know" spin, to float the idea that as long as a question, any question, remains, there can be no possible legitimacy* (* = and I have a funny feeling that for the next eight years, there will not exactly be any shortage of "questions"... how convenient!).

user-pic

Yep, links are your friend. Here is proof the earth is flat:

http://theflatearthsociety.org/forum/index.php?PHPSESSID=7d00ccb82e4994ba4a64cc5a83adfc01&

user-pic

There's as much definitive proof of where he was born as there is about any other president. You just choose to disregard it.

Where Dubya's birth certificate? Where's Reagan's birth certificate?

Doesn't matter. Obama's mother was a US citizen, i.e., Obama is a natural born US citizen and eligible to be president whether he's born in Kansas, Kenya, Katmandu, Key West, Kalamazoo or KissMyAss.

Deal with it, nutters!

user-pic

Let's see your birth certificate, whackjob. We need to verify - beyond any doubt - your standing to be able to ask this question.

user-pic

Psssst! Hey! Wacko. Over here....

I have a secret to share with you and, by all the gods, it'll knock your socks off! But don't let it get around, because it could cause some real bad, bad problems with the process of electing our POTUS.

See, there were maybe as many as three people who snuck into the job of presidency (sorry, I'm not including that little trouble-maker Jeff Davis; he doesn't really count):

Washington, Jefferson and Adams were not born as US citizens and they were still let in as presidents!!!!.

Seriously, man — if this leaks out, we are all going to be in seriously BIG trouble!

Maybe we should pass another law that removes them from the roles, because with that stain on our record, how are we ever going to find time to do something important like rescue our country from sinking under the waves of supply-side, no oversight idiocy actively promoted by anti-American "real" citizens who were also elected to high offices?

user-pic

Yup, yup....

user-pic

When they wrote the Constitution, they needed to satisfy the Southern States, so some special language had to be used. This whole thing is about slaves. They would not allow someone to become president who was a slave, or born a slave and later freed. The "natural born citizen" phrase covers this. It is taken directly from the laws of the Roman Republic, which, except for Iceland and 1600's England, was the main example they had to follow. I believe that the post civil war amendments effectively removed this part of the Constitution.

user-pic

"natural born citizen"--wait, C-sections aren't allowed?

user-pic

You're absolutely right. Every time I've heard these racist monsters make that criticism, it's undeniable. Just wait until they, the hardcore conservative right-wingers, Southerners, toss Michael Steele out. It will just accentuate what we already know. I'm betting that Rep. Posey is one of those Steele-haters too.

By the way, ever since Bush was wedged into office by the Supreme Court, Karl Rove and all the rests of the apologists have been trying to legitimize him. Ridiculous.

user-pic

More important, how does Posey's claim that "Opponents of President Bush used the 2000 election results and the court decisions to question the legitimacy of President Bush to serve as President,", connect with his effort to paint Barack Obama as possibly not a natural born citizen of the U.S., and somehow illegitimate as President? He isn't stating it outright, but is doing it via 'wink, wink, nod, nod'.

user-pic

See my earlier timeless prose, acf... that entire sentence is all about the ongoing drip-drip-drip of the Republican rewriting of history ("the OBAMA economy"; "the BUSH recovery", "we only lost in Viet Nam because of the PROTESTORS", yada yada).

Again, "BUSH v. Gore" becomes those miserable librul trial lawyers attempting to use our sacred courts to steal the election from that decent, Christian, white, flag-lapel pin-wearing self-made Texas bidnessman.

It's not over for these people. It's never over. They'll stay at it until no one remembers that it was Bush who literally stole an American presidential election, using a friendly Supreme Court to pull specious legal "theory" out of their asses, and then declare that this decision, by the highest court in the land, was a one-time only Blue Plate Special. Jesus.

user-pic

My opinion, for whatever that's worth, is that this is more about general ignorance than about race or ethnicity. As the election's demographics showed, though racial bigotry might have offered motive to a distinct yet very finite percentage of voters, it was clearly not a factor in the ultimate outcome. If it had been, Barack Obama would have lost to John McCain.

But what should also appall us are those apparently still-large numbers of Americans who don't quite realize, even in this golden anniversary year of its formal admission into the Union, that Hawaii is in fact an integral part of the United States.

As recently as July 1, 2007 at Amarillo (TX) Airport, a local TSA employee refused to accept my Hawaii driver's license as valid ID for entry into the gate area, and asked to see my Hawaiian passport.

What made this incident even more astonishing, particularly considering where I was at the time in West Texas, is that I'm not of Polynesian or Asian ancestry, but am German-Irish! I actually had to appeal to the woman's supervisor for his reluctant intervention -- and even then, he had to call HIS boss for verification about Hawaii's political status!

If a larger percentage of our country's citizenry were geographically / socially / historically literate, these sorts of political straws about Hawaii birth certificates and island passports would simply be non-starters, and thus denied to the ignorant fringe elements amongst us.

user-pic

Because of the rule we white folks instituted long ago: "it's not racism as long as you don't say the word 'nigger'."

Anything else, and it's a case of "you're oversensitive", or "we should give him the benefit of the doubt", or something.

user-pic

The answer is easy. Obviously Republicans like him do not know how to authenticate a birth in any of our states. It is very simple. Write the State agency in charge of records and request the information. In fact, the Hawaiian officials have already authenticated Obama's Hawaiian birth. But this guy and many Republicans seem so dull witted they simply do not understand the simplest thing about genealogy. But what the heck, this guy has no interest in facts. He sounds just like the typical Southern racist to me. What else can we expect out of a racist like him? Nothing!!!!!

user-pic

Why don't we render this congressman, interrogate him enhanced like, and see if he is a citizen?

user-pic

I support extraordinary rendition of the distinguished Congressman to verify his citizenship via "enhanced" interrogation methods, provided that our spokesman (Eric?) make clear that questioning him is not intended as an insult.

His party assured us that the United States does not torture, so he should have no problem with us doing a full Cheney on him to rip out the truth.

user-pic

Naaah, doesn't need to be that nasty. Obama should just support the bill fully, and stipulate that an amendment to it should be tests of IQ and basic world facts for candidates for Congress.

user-pic

If by "render" you mean slowly cook the fat out of him, well, can I help?

user-pic

"Posey has submitted a bill to require all presidential candidates to submit a birth certificate -- which Posey says is needed in order to remove this issue as a reason to question any president's legitimacy."

Yes, Bill, the questioning of Obama's birthplace by desperate wingnuts was just as significant as the Supreme Court issuing a non-precedent-setting decision in favor of Bush in 2000.

Man, these GOP nutcases are the gift that just keeps on giving.

user-pic

You know just like Cokie Roberts demonstrated when she exposed her ignorance about Hawaii on national television, these morons like Rep. Posey are more than likely really just to stupid to know that Hawaii is part of the United States.

user-pic

Memo to Rep. Posey:

Modify your bill to include all Senate and Congressional candidates too. And let's see that certificate, while you're at it, you bloody pompous jackass.

user-pic

Yeah the timing is strange. Though I have to admit I'm surprised this is such a new issue - I would think that people registering as presidential candidates already have to produce a birth certificate. Before now, no one has been actually checking that candidates fit the consititutional rules for running for president??? That would be weird.

Aren't birth certificates publically available anyway? Maybe not...

user-pic

Presenting a birth certificate demonstrating U. S. birth might have been a problem for all those ealy presidents who were born in the British Colonies before births were certified.

user-pic

Does it need to be presented in person in each state when they register? To whom do they show it, the governor or would a judge be sufficient? Certainly not one of those liberal judges! Are they required to provide biometric ID or is a photo ID acceptable?
The list of particulars could go on and on. The devil is in the details when you're dealing with people who want to knit pick just to be arseholes.
Take Norm Coleman as an example.

user-pic

The conservatives, not just right wingers but the general conservatives as well, will be trying to use this trash like they used Lewinsky on Clinton.

They will throw their tantrum and try to hang it over Obama's presidency to ruin it. And Fox, CNN, MSNBC and the rest will oblige them. Just watch.

user-pic

Except Clinton did bang Monica. They will be using this like Vince Foster on Clinton.

user-pic

But Clinton didn't "bang" Lewinsky, in the sense that "bang" is usually used to mean. Of course, when slamming Clinton, being truthful or precise has never been a requirement.

user-pic

"Opponents of President Obama are raising the birth certificate issue as a means of questioning his eligibility to serve as president."

The use of the present tense is damning.

Obama has already produced his birth certificate, and crackpots and still questioning his eligibility, so what's the point?

One of the badges of a crackpot is that mere proof is never sufficient.

So by Posey's own standards, the bill is at best a waste of time. At worst, it's pandering.

I'm leaning towards pandering.

user-pic

You are right that there exists no form or format of this true and valid documentation which can satisfy these yahoos. Any information, confirmation, witness account(s), of any kind will only lead to new and disturbing questions, etc.

If he were to totally nail them down, the theory would just mutate that he was switched at birth or some such.

Since virtually every Democrat will vote against Posey's impudent bill, he's engaging in the equivalent of a rhetorical exercise. Speaker Pelosi should check his office space, though -- he may have too much, and some of it may be needed by e.g. cleaning staff.

user-pic

Exactly. I kind of wonder if this isn't more red meat, proposed with the full knowledge that it will go nowhere, so Posey and the GOP can turn around and bitch about how those nasty Dems stopped them from reaching the truth.

Shorter Posey: "It's never been a problem before, because we've always elected white guys. But now, you, know..."

Passive-agressive drama with a big helping of delusion on the side. This is basically the GOP thinking they get to pick and choose who's American and who's not. Prettied up with concern trolling and "aw, shucks, I'm just trying to do the right thing," but still ugly.

user-pic

"This was not meant as an insult to the president. It is simply meant as a way to clarify future election laws and to dispel the issue so we can move on with doing business for the country."

Of course, the best way to dispel the issue and move on with doing business is to stop pandering to the crackpots and stop legitimizing the issue.

In other words, stop feeding the trolls, Posey.

user-pic

Bill Posey should be questioned about his motivation for this sham by Jack Bauer. After Jack fractures a couple of kneecaps, old Bill will sing like a canary.

user-pic

Listen to you: "Let's beat the crap out of Posey." Zeig Heil to you, too. Sheesh.

user-pic

"Let's beat the crap out of Posey." If you're going to misquote me, at least use brackets. Besides, it's not a "let's..." assignment, it's a Jack Bauer assignment for the good of the country.

user-pic

I like the way he tries to tie President Obama's birth certificate crap to the outright THEFT of the Presidency by Georgie Dubya in 2000. How absolutely ridiculous can these whack job repugnicans get????

user-pic

These comments seem rather odd to me. I proudly voted for Obama, but I can understand that to conform to the Constitution, there should be a way to validate that the candidate is a natural born US citizen. That just makes sense. Hey, I had to show my birth certificate to renew my driver's license which I have had for 45 years now. Why should I not have to do it to become POTUS?
I haven't seen Obama's birth certificate and it is my understanding that it isn't in the public domain. There is an unsigned "Certificate of Live Birth" filed several days after the birth but I don't think that is an official birth certificate.
I'd like to see this issue resolved, even as an Obama supporter.

user-pic

Sure you are a proud supporter bill. Obama has a driver's license and passport and registered to vote. He's had to produce his birth certificate numerous times in the past, just like every american citizen. This is a bunch of bullsh*t and your post is a bunch of bullsh*t. Lush go work on your radio show.

Mcbush wasn't a natural born american citizen based on your and the lunatic fringe's analysis. He was born in a foreign country. Where was the outcry from you loons then?

user-pic

Thanks for dispatching this "supporter," Michael A. Well done.

user-pic

ROFLMAO... I remember seeing this gimmick begin, during the days of Tricky Dick... anyone remember "Democrats For Nixon"?

You couldn't go a week, without picking up your local paper and reading a letter to the editor: "I am a proud Democrat, who voted for FDR and Adlai Stevenson and John F. Kennedy... but I an just SO concerned for our country, right now, that I believe Richard Nixon to be the yada yada bullshit..."

(p.s... this meme showed up again in both Bush eras!)

user-pic

You're very right about this. And they got that odious Zell Miller and Traitor Joe to go on national TV opposing their own party's candidates, not that their loyalty or bona fides should be questioned in any way.

user-pic

I haven't seen your birth certificate either. Therefore, you must be from Kenya.

user-pic

Have you seen Bill Clinton's birth certificate? What about Ronald Reagan or Jimmy Carter or either of the Bushes?

WE have NEVER seen any president's original birth certificate because no other president has been asked to show one. Yet, Obama has to repeatedly respond to a question that has never been asked of any other president, simply because he's black and has an unusual name.

The "birthers" fail to acknowledge that Obama's mother was a citizen so it doesn't matter where he was born.

They fail to acknowledge that (a) any child born to a US citizen is automatically a citizen and (b) any child born on American soil is automatically a citizen.

They pretend that there is some ambiguity about what being a natural born citizen means. There is not. It's natural born (a citizen from the day you're born) v. naturalized (i.e. Schwarzenegger & Albright.)

This whole thing is such a ridiculous sham and you, Bill, are full of shit.

user-pic

Certainly a President's credentials to be president should be officially certified but let's also include a psychological exam and a drug test!

user-pic

I hope that Posey's constituents are happy; obviously this is the kind of legislation that they sent him to Washington to produce. Moronic fools....with all of the problems that this country has, this is the legislation that this idiot puts forth.

user-pic

Please don't take this as pedantic; just the point that this lout isn't producing any legislation at all, just a draft that has no chance of passing. It has to go through committee first, I believe. It will never even get out of committee, as every Dem on the Committee including the chairman will vote against it, if a committee vote is even allowed and it probably won't be.

So you could say, is this the kind of *antics* his constituents are looking to him to supply. He ain't producin' no legislation. Jackass that he is.

user-pic

Mom, age 90, says she saw ( on Fox News, of course) Obama's grandmother say that he was born in Kenya and she was there. She asked me why she would say that if it weren't true. I had no idea why she would say it. My son suggests that Obama's father was also named Barack Obama, so maybe with the translation involved, she was confused as to who they were talking about. Of course she was there for his father's birth! In any case, yeah Fox News for once again muddying the waters.

user-pic

The opponents of Florida Republicans have made accusations that question the legitimacy of Florida Republicans serving in office. My bill requires them to prove that they have not texted underage pages about their wank habits, demonstrate that they have never worn what opponents would deride as "tit-hugging spandex" at a rodeo, have never illegally colluded with a sibling to alter the outcome of a presidential election, and have never offered 20$ to an unknown individual for the privilege of providing oral gratification to said individual in a public restroom.

In order to clarify, this was not meant as an insult to these officials. It is simply meant as a way to clarify future election laws and to dispel the issue so we can move on with doing business for the country."

user-pic

I don't get it. Hawaii release a copy of his birth certificate to these lunatics even though other prez candidates were not required to do so.

No matter what you agree to with birther lunatics, it will never be enough. They'll just find something else to whine about or claim it is a fake.

And we all know this is asked of Obama only because he is black and has a Kenyan father. This is racist and pathetic.

Where is the proof that McCain was born in the U.S.?

user-pic

You are correct. It is a "zombie" issue that will not die, despite the facts.

And McCain, ironically, he wasn't born in the U.S. He was born in Panama. In the Panama Canal Zone.

user-pic

"Zombie issue" for sure...outright fantasy is all they have left, they lost in real time and all I can say to them is "It's OVER. LIVE WITH IT!"

user-pic

>>I don't get it. Hawaii release a copy of his birth certificate to these lunatics even though other prez candidates were not required to do so.>>

Absolutely not! Hawaii has already released a certified copy of Obama's birth certificate. The nutters said it was a fake. Hawaii then verified that it was authentic in every way. Nutters said that's not good enough; they need to see the original one locked in the vault.

If that is released, they'll say "not good enough. Obama has enough clout to fake that, too."

Even the birth annoucement published in the newspapres in August, 1961 don't satisfy them. They say that it was either faked later or that Obama's parents lied when they said he was born there. Nevermind that these announcements don't come from the parents. They come from the bureau of vital statistics of all the live births.

There's nothing Obama can do to satisfy these people and make these rumors go away so he shouldn't even try. Let the wingers make themselves even more irrelevant.

user-pic

Well, that is my point. There will be no end to it. In reality, the requirement of being born in the U.S. has its limits to what can be proven.

Smells awful similar to the Richard Mellon Scaife episode insisting that the Clintons had people murdered to cover up Whitewater.

user-pic

FreeRider says: Hawaii has already released a certified copy of Obama's birth certificate. The nutters said it was a fake. Hawaii then verified that it was authentic in every way.

Those are blatant lies. Hawaii never released BHO's certificate. He uploaded a picture of what he supposedly got from them to his website.

And, Hawaii has never verified anything about the picture on BHO's site. The only thing they said is that they have a valid cert on file. They did not say anything about the picture on his site.

It would be illegal for them to verify the picture on his site or to reveal the contents of the one they have on file.

user-pic

You're right. Wow, I never thought of that. I saw on fox today I think that they said that he was born on Mars. He's not even human. He is an alien life form sent from mars to take away our freedoms and our woman folk. Amazing that I didn't see it before. Thank you for the wonderful insights and thanks to fox news.

user-pic

From PolitiFact: (I guess they're lying, too!)

When the birth certificate arrived from the Obama campaign it confirmed his name as the other documents already showed it. Still, we took an extra step: We e-mailed it to the Hawaii Department of Health, which maintains such records, to ask if it was real.

"It's a valid Hawaii state birth certificate," spokesman Janice Okubo told us.

. . .

At PolitiFact.com, we're all about original sources. We don't take anyone at their word or take the reporting of other media organizations as proof. We go to the heart of the story, the source of the truth — original, corroborating documents.

When the official documents were questioned, we went looking for more answers. We circled back to the Department of Health, had a newsroom colleague bring in her own Hawaii birth certificate to see if it looks the same (it's identical). But every answer triggered more questions.

And soon enough, after going to every length possible to confirm the birth certificate's authenticity, you start asking, what is reasonable here?

Because if this document is forged, then they all are.

user-pic

1. When Politifact refers to the BC "arriving", they mean a picture of his supposed COLB, not a physical copy.

2. As I pointed out above, on the very same page, Okubo says: "I don't know that it's possible for us to even say beyond a doubt what the image on the site represents."

3. Politifact punted, assuming that he must have a valid cert since others have probably seen it. That's the same thing Madoff investors thought: he must not be a scam because of all those other people.

Politifact cannot be trusted.

user-pic

Hey, you said Factcheck.org can't be trusted either because they're connected with the Annenberg Center and Obama once served on a board funded by the Annenberg Center. Factcheck states that they say the certified copy in person.

You said that the Hawaii officials (including the Republican governor) are covering for Obama.

According to you, the only persons who can be trusted are loons like you and the good folks at NoQuarter.

'Splain please: why would they fake a Hawaii birth certificate since it's not necessary? Remember, Obama's mother is a US citizen.

user-pic

Of course, it's irrelevant that the Annenbergs themselves endorsed McCain: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/10/08/mccains-trumpets-endorsem_n_132954.html

I love how the conspiracy has to expand to include McCain being in on it.

user-pic

H.R 666

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

This act may be cited as the Wingnut Recovery Act, requiring all citizens short on common sense to wear their tin-foil hats whenever appearing in public.

Cheif sponsor: GTFOOH

Cosponsers: ______________________________

user-pic

Co-sign. Or is that Co-sponsor?

user-pic

Co-sponsor, with ground cables.

user-pic

It doesn't matter if this smear is debunked by Jesus himself, they will still use it as a tool to weaken Obama's presidency.

And their rabid, lunatic followers will lap it up. And the media whores will lend it credibility.

This bill is just the start...Just watch...

user-pic

It's not really weakening anything. If anything, it just further marginalizes the extreme remnants of the GOP.

user-pic

I think it does just the opposite. This issue only appeals to the lunatic fringe and it is just one more issue that frames the Republican Party as a bunch of angry incompetent loser lunatics. These are serious times. People are fed up with this b.s.

user-pic

ditto; either that, or they're begining a scorched-earth campaign. If they can't control it, they will set it ablaze so no one else can.

Not to sound paranoid, but the timing of this economic collapse seems to have that aura to it. It seems almost as if the greedy rich would rather lose half their billions to recession and depression rather than pay it as wages to the middle class.

user-pic

Well, you're absolutely right, they are indeed beginning a scorched earth campaign. As I posted earlier, think of the Clinton drip-drip-drip of "scandals" and "questions"... the idea was to produce a cumulative feeling of "something's always going wrong with these people". After awhile, your ratings slump from fatigue at your just being there.

I think it was the head of one of the GOP election committees, who recently blurted-out that their main focus was going to be to "drive up Obama's negatives".

The GOOD news is that the American people have seen this movie before, and initially, it all seems to be backfiring in their pudgy white faces.

The BAD news is: not with the MSM, it isn't. Running what amounts to the world's longest commercial for GOP spin can still hurt the President and the Dems, to some degree.

We need, quite seriously, to stay on the mainstream media like flies to shit, and make a really unseemly stink, every time they spread one of these right-wing brain turds.

Let's start with yesterday's WaPo front-page (I think) diatribe about how Obama's defending himself against "the Obama economy" meme, only shows that it's partisan politics as usual, with this typical Democrat.

THAT WaPo weasel needs his fucking car egged.

user-pic

Until recently, it was widely believed that "natural born" referred to the method of delivery and was the founding fathers' way of prohibiting a Caesarian leader. All that changed in 2000, of course, when the Supreme Court installed a butthole baby as president.

user-pic

First, Obama DID produce a birth certificate and second, do we really think this idiot would have introduced this bill at all if the Panama Canal Zone born McCain had won the election?

user-pic

What a crock of Sh*t!!!

Does Senator Posey think the FBI, the NSA, the CIA, and rest of the alphabet soup of security and intelligence agencies as well as the entire Election Commissions Board, have not checked to see if a candidate is qualified to be THE PRESIDENT?????

Since being a natural born citizen is already a requirement for the office of The President...
maybe someone should ask Senator Posey if he thinks those agencies are not doing their job???

Or maybe Senator Posey is just a pathetic, racist, sore losing sonfoabitch!!?


user-pic

I pick option 2.

user-pic

McCain was born on US territory for all intents and purposes. The wingdings only use protection of rule of law when it suits their purposes. (see guantanamo, habeas corpus, birthright citizenship etc.)
This bill isn't going anywhere....

user-pic

NOBAMA TEH MUSLIN TERRIST HAz BEAN GROOMED FrOM BIRTH BY ILLUM1NATI MASON LIZzARD PEOPLE 2 HIJACK OUR USA NATION AND MAKE EVERYDAY RAMUDUMB!!!1!!

ONLy A FEW OF US KNOW TEH TERR1BLE TRUHT ANR YOU RED DIAPER DOPER BABY LIBRULS CANT STAND IT!1!!1!!!

user-pic

You write like our latest pseudo-troll, "JOHN"

user-pic

Hey! Who let the cat in here?

user-pic

Are The Onion offices closed on Saturday?

user-pic

Well said for a person with a minimal IQ.

user-pic

I still like that avatar!

user-pic

While we are still at this dead issue story:
Let's have all GOP candidates submit to IQ tests, truth-o-meter tests, criminal background checks, and revelations of any misadventures with prostitutes, Congressional pages, or member of the same sex in airport bathrooms, and finally check with Rush to see if they are okay.

user-pic

Not a problem with the birth certificate as long as a standardized IQ test is also administered and the results published at the same time.

user-pic


What are these guys' end game? IF Barack Obama is proven to be from Kenya, Kamchatka or Krypton, what is their next step? Impeachment? I doubt it. They don't have the votes, and they know it. And even if they did, it's not like the Miss America pageant, where the 1st runner-up takes over the crown. McCain will NOT become President, Joe Biden will. So what have they accomplished? Alienating another few generations of black voters, regardless of how many token blacks they pick as RNC chair.

user-pic

IQ test > birth certificates

user-pic

"This was not meant as an insult to the president. It is simply meant as a way to clarify future election laws and to dispel the issue so we can move on with doing business for the country."

Yeah, right.
It's an insult to the current president, it's an insult to the state of Hawaii, and it makes the GOoPers look even more like fools than they already did.
And it shows how little they know about the Constitution and law, that they can't understand that being the child of a citizen and born in the US both make him a natural-born citizen.

user-pic

I'M SO TIRED OF THE RACE CARD BEING USED WHEN IT COMES TO OBAMA.
FIRST OF ALL HE IS NOT AFRO AMERICAN.
HE IS A HALF BREED. HE IS NOT BLACK.
BLACK IS A BLACK MOTHER AND FATHER.
HIS MOTHER WAS WHITE AS RICE. SO DEAL WITH IT.
SECOND OF ALL.
HE HAS SPENT OVER 1 MILLION DOLLARS FIGHTING LAWSUITS TO MAKE HIM SHOW HIS REAL BIRTH CERTIFICATE AND NOT THE ALTERED FAKE PIECE OF PAPER THAT IS ON THE WEB.
HOW DO I KNOW? I AM A HAWAIIAN CITIZEN BORN THE SAME YEAR AND SAME MONTH.
I CAN ASSURE YOU MY BIRTH CERTIFICATE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THAN WHAT THEY HAVE PUT UP ON THE WEB.
IT IS A FAKE.
HE IS A FAKE.
HE WAS BORN IN KENYA. MOM FLEW TO HAWAII AFTER HE WAS OLD ENOUGH TO FLY.
REGISTERED HIS BIRTH IN HAWAII BUT NEVER OBTAINED A TRUE CERTIFICATE BECAUSE SHE COULDN'T.
JOHN MCCAIN WAS CHALLENGED BY THE DEMS ON HIS BIRTH CERTIFICATE AND HE PROMPTLY PROVIDED THE REAL DEAL AND HANDED IT TO THEM NOT POSTED SOME FAKE PIECE OF (((( ON THE NET.
SO GROW UP YOU REVERSE RACIST THUGS.
YOU ARE NOTHING BUT WANNABEES THAT HAVE DONE NOTHING FOR THIS COUNTRY AND NEITHER HAS YOUR ANCESTORS.
YOU ONLY WISH HE WAS BLACK AND EVERYONE WANTS TO MAKE HIM BLACK BUT HIS IS JUST AS MUCH WHITE AS BLACK.

user-pic

OK, post yours as definitive evidence. Or do we take its absence as conclusive proof you're a baldfaced liar?

user-pic

I'M SO TIRED OF THE RACE CARD BEING USED WHEN IT COMES TO OBAMA.
FIRST OF ALL HE IS NOT AFRO AMERICAN.
HE IS A HALF BREED. HE IS NOT BLACK.
BLACK IS A BLACK MOTHER AND FATHER.
HIS MOTHER WAS WHITE AS RICE. SO DEAL WITH IT.
SECOND OF ALL.
HE HAS SPENT OVER 1 MILLION DOLLARS FIGHTING LAWSUITS TO MAKE HIM SHOW HIS REAL BIRTH CERTIFICATE AND NOT THE ALTERED FAKE PIECE OF PAPER THAT IS ON THE WEB.
HOW DO I KNOW? I AM A HAWAIIAN CITIZEN BORN THE SAME YEAR AND SAME MONTH.
I CAN ASSURE YOU MY BIRTH CERTIFICATE IS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THAN WHAT THEY HAVE PUT UP ON THE WEB.
IT IS A FAKE.
HE IS A FAKE.
HE WAS BORN IN KENYA. MOM FLEW TO HAWAII AFTER HE WAS OLD ENOUGH TO FLY.
REGISTERED HIS BIRTH IN HAWAII BUT NEVER OBTAINED A TRUE CERTIFICATE BECAUSE SHE COULDN'T.
JOHN MCCAIN WAS CHALLENGED BY THE DEMS ON HIS BIRTH CERTIFICATE AND HE PROMPTLY PROVIDED THE REAL DEAL AND HANDED IT TO THEM NOT POSTED SOME FAKE PIECE OF (((( ON THE NET.
SO GROW UP YOU REVERSE RACIST THUGS.
YOU ARE NOTHING BUT WANNABEES THAT HAVE DONE NOTHING FOR THIS COUNTRY AND NEITHER HAS YOUR ANCESTORS.
YOU ONLY WISH HE WAS BLACK AND EVERYONE WANTS TO MAKE HIM BLACK BUT HIS IS JUST AS MUCH WHITE AS BLACK.

user-pic

What is going on today? They are out in droves. It must be the weather.

The thing that is really stupid about these ridiculous arguments is that there is absolutely no reason for her to high tail it back to the us from kenya. He would be an american citizen wherever he was born. Why would she do it? She was plotting to make him president when he was born? Furthermore, knowing that she was giving birth and the state of medical care in kenya, why would she go there to give birth? Expecially, if she was going to high tail it back to the us and manipulate all the stuff that allegedly was manipultated?

None of this makes sense. More important, why am I wasting my time.

user-pic

Who did McCain show his certificate to? How do we know it was real? Why wouldn't he just pay off some report to lie about it? I certainly haven't seen it. Obviously, he never showed his birth certificate. John McCain was born on Mars.

user-pic

"HALF-BREED... that's all I ever heard... HALF-BREED.... how I learned to hate the word..."

:-P

user-pic

Poor dumb schmuck. Chalk it up to his name. I'm sure he took all kinds of grief for it when he was a kid. He's obviously suffering from post-traumatic dumbness.

user-pic

certificate of live human birth? could Posey pass that test? the human part would be fairly hard for him, I think.

user-pic

It's pretty simple.

The controversy exists because people in a position to actually know the truth claim Obama was not born in the U.S. In fact, his grandmother may be the only person alive who has actual firsthand knowledge of his birth.

Snd the answer, just like Obama re-taking the oath, is that to remove any possibility that Obama is ineligible he need to release the actual original birth certificate, which exists in a vault in Hawaii, rather than a computer printout of the data in a computer.

Obama is the only one that can resolve this. And he refuses. Where there's smoke.......

user-pic

Yes, it is pretty simple. Let me clarify for a dim bulb such as yourself.

*Obama was born in Hawaii in 1961.
*The State of Hawaii has, many times over, confirmed and verified this simple fact.
*Obama has a driver's license and a US Passport.
*Obama is now the President of the United States

So get over it already. Nothing you slobbering idiots can say or do will remotely change the fact that McCain lost and Obama won. He is your president and there's nothing you can do about it.

I've realized that all the so-called doubters out there, don't believe the story either. They are just sore losers who are looking for something, anything, to scream and whine and flail about. They know Obama is a US Citizen, but they persist because they have nothing left to throw at him.

This is what amuses me about conspiracies and the morons who believe in them; they can just continue to move the goalposts every time a piece of solid evidence emerges to refute their amateurish laughable claims.

Case in point, the Factcheck.org post about this.

Anyone with an ounce of sanity or reason can conclude after reading the Factcheck post that yes, Obama is a US citizen as they have examined the document themselves.

But the kooks claim, no, that's not real, it's made up, without offering ONE single piece of evidence otherwise. Oh, some blogger sitting at home denies it, therefore it must be a hoax. Don't you realize how stupid you sound?

I love it. I hope the unhinged crackpots persist with this story. It only makes the GOP look that much more out of touch with reality, as if they need anymore piling on lately.

user-pic

Where there's smoke, there's the crack you're obviously smoking, pinhead.

user-pic

Here's the think:

Obama could resolve this, but he won't because you whackjobs are irrelevant and it's a lot more fun to get you losers to waste your pathetic lives obsessing over this fantasy off yours.

If there's a fire, then surely you can find it instead of just suggesting it. We'll be waiting when you do.

Also, the thing about his grandmother is a lie, just like the Whitey Tape. You can't use WorldNetDaily and NoQuarter and their right-wing buddies as "sources."

user-pic

I said it before and I'll say it again. There is no quantity of irrefutable evidence that would ever satisfy people such as yourself. And the reason why nothing he can provide will every satisfy you is that you are a run of the mill sore loser.

You lost badly in a fair contest, to a black guy mind you, and you can't take it like a man.

BTW, the real un-American here is anybody with a brain who would have wanted Sarah Palin in direct line to be President.

user-pic

I think it would be a mistake on the part of congressional Dems to simply ignore or vote down this reprehensible piece of crap legislation.

I suggest that it be turned to our advantage by adding, which we have the votes to do, language that expresses and confirms that "congress agrees that it is a legal fact that the current POTUS is a US citizen, is constitutionally eligible to be POTUS, was legally elected POTUS and duly sworn in as POTUS by the Chief Justice of the SCOTUS. Barak Hussein Obama is the 44th President of the United States of America and his legitimacy as such is not subject to question."

Let the rethug congressional bastards have their little "dig" IF they endorse BHO's legitimacy as POTUS. Make them publicly state their questions and If necessary have congressional hearings bringing related documents and testimony into the record.

Of course, it will not satisfy the "wackos" but it should put an end to any further echoing of their "questions" by the MSM.


user-pic

I just sent this excellent suggestion to my rep, Emmanual Cleaver, and I suggest all TPMers to do same:

https://writerep.house.gov/writerep/welcome.shtml

Like I described it to him, this would indeed be a feat of political jujitsu against the reps of rapid caps-lock crowd.