TPMDC
« GOP Ad Attacks Dem Candidate As Corrupt Businessman | Home | Poll: GOP Senator Burr Down By Three Against Potential Dem Opponent »

Will Republicans Go Nookyoular over Budget Antics?

As I mentioned earlier, today's breaking budget news is that the congressional budget committees released their budget blueprints. There are some notable differences between the House and Senate resolutions, and both differ from the president's proposal--the House plan, for instance, will drop the deficit to $600 billion over five years, compared to the $500 billion in the Senate plan, whereas the Congressional Budget Office predicted higher deficits under Obama's outline. Still the administration and congressional leaders are playing these differences down.

There's some good reason for that, but the bigger issue still looms in the background: reconciliation. Reconciliation enables certain types of fiscal legislation--including, significantly, some of Barack Obama's major agenda items--to be bundled together and voted on immune from the threat of filibuster.

Republicans see this as a major threat and for the last several days have been lividly decrying the entire process, threatening to respond to any attempts to put health and energy reforms into a reconciliation bill by going 'nuclear'. Nuclear in this instance has nothing to do with atomic physics or with filibustering judges but instead with a senatorial tendency to indulge in hyperbole when describing their powers.

Politico reported that a Republican Senate aid threatened that his party would respond to reconciliation by "shutting down the Senate through the use of parliamentary maneuvers such as forcing the reading of bills and amendments and prohibiting committees from meeting for more than a few hours at a time."

That would really gum up the works! But here's the thing. Budget committee chairman Kent Conrad does not include a so-called "reconciliation directive" in his budget resolution, and without that directive, there's typically no reconciliation bill at all. That could quell some of the Republican outrage, but it's by no means the final word. The House resolution does include such a directive, which can still make its way into the final resolution.

This sets the stage, in theory, for the scenario Elana reported on yesterday, wherein Democrats "hide the reconciliation ball" and, perhaps, include major health legislation in a reconciliation bill if the Senate doesn't get its act together and come to a bipartisan agreement on reform.

That raises the issue of how all the Senate complications and Republican threats are weighing on the House's plans. On that question a leadership staffer said, basically, there's no reason to take the option off the table. "I think on the House side, there are a lot of backseat drivers for Harry Reid," the staffer said. "House Democrats will not be the ones who worry about that threat."


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Good, make them go nuclear. It's not like obstructionism has either worked out for them politically, or even been particularly successful at obstructing, thus far.

user-pic

"Nuclear in this instance has nothing to do with atomic physics or with filibustering judges but instead with a senatorial tendency to indulge in hyperbole when describing their powers."


Hyperbole is what Republicans have been doing this since day one and that is their problem. At a certain point it starts to sound like the teacher in Charlie Brown.

The GOP should go re-read The Shepherd Boy and the Wolf. At a certain point, people tune out.

user-pic

Translation: If you don't let us stealthily thwart the agenda people resoundingly voted for last election, we'll obstruct it by means that will insure the next election will be an extinction event for us!"

Boy, that is a terrifying threat, isn't it?

Btw, great post.

user-pic

Absolutely mortifying.

user-pic

Really, what does it say about your political party when keep threatening to go nuclear or use the nuclear option on your own government?

user-pic

Can we send them to Gitmo if they go nuclear?

user-pic

Just move forward with the reconciliation already. The GOP has already demonstrated that they have no interest in negotiating in good faith. Anyone that believes that it will be possible to develop bipartisan health care reform is dreaming.

user-pic

JJP I love yall to death but we got to put some muscle behind our mouth

Obama told us from day ONE ..that he can't do this by himself.

He has done the most POWERFUL thing he can..put the changes we want in the budget!! Where it is filibuster prove..now WE have to PUSH it through

We have to activate and mobilize everybody in our e mail addresses, everybody that is your neighbor and friend has to understand why this is important. TELL THEM

The media is NOT on our side, just like during the campaign. WE have to BE the CHANGE!!!

Tell them to write/call their congress person and tell them to pass HIS budget.

The budget is THE CHANGE we voted for.

Obama NEEDS us.

He needs our voices..WE ARE THE CHANGE we have been WAITING for

PLease act on it

iF WE WANT CHANGE

we have to ACT!!! MOVE this BUDGET through Congress...channel your outrage into this

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/03/26/house-...

Don;t leave OUR PRESIDENT hanging...we are the ones that make his POWER meaningful

CHANGE is US!!!


Get on it!!

Tell everyone spread the word,.

Make them DO what we VOTED for!!
edit

user-pic

There really is only one way to respond to that sort of political threat - dare them to do it. The alternative is that the threat gives opponents power eternally at no cost. If it's a real problem, make them do it and find a systematic accommodation. If it's not a real problem (which I am reasonably sure is the case here), get it off the table, strip it from their quiver, etc.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Elana
Schor

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio


Latest Videos




Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address