TPMDC
« Poll: McAuliffe Continues To Lead Virginia Dem Gubernatorial Primary | Home | TPMDC Morning Roundup »

GOPer: Climate Bill Will Create 'Global Warming Gestapo'

During today's marathon markup hearing before the House Energy and Commerce Committee, Rep. Steve Scalise (R-LA) argued that, by creating federal building standards, the Waxman-Markey cap and trade bill will unleash a "Global Warming Gestapo" on the good people of Louisiana and elsewhere.

Waxman: "I'd like to ask a question of the gentleman (Mr. Scalise), you've said global warming Gestapo, what does that mean?" Scalise: It basically is the powers that are vested in the Secretary under Section 201 of this cap and trade energy tax, to go into someone's house, number one to go in, and then charge them. Waxman: "So if anybody does something you don't like you call them Gestapo? What do you think of the people who run other government agencies, do you think the government is made up of Gestapo?" Scalise: "I don't think the government should be able to tell somebody if they're living in their home and they're abiding by all the laws that they're an unlawful occupant of their house, that's the terminology of the bill, that's frightening."

Waxman: "I would welcome the expression of your point of view, but I would like to request that perhaps that's a little strong to say Gestapo."

That's a new one! The GOP has been sort of throwing a number of different (and dubious) anti-cap and trade talking points at the wall to see what sticks. They've got the "energy tax" tag down, and, in the Senate, they're thinking it might be a good idea to say that, by working on climate change legislation, Democrats are in the pocket of big business.

But Reductio ad Hitlerum usually doesn't get people very far. Even in the House of Representatives.

Late update: Brad Johnson has more.


12 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Do Republicans have the foggiest notion of what World War II was and what Nazis and Fascists were? Maybe no one should be allowed to make Nazi comparisons without passing a history test. I guess that makes me a history nazi.

user-pic

Will this gestapo have the power to take away my guns?

user-pic

Not until we can get the terrorists out of Gitmo and into your neighborhood.

user-pic

has anyone told the wingnuts that pulling a godwin means you lose the argument?

user-pic

I am waiting for Embarrassing Eric Cantor, a (very) conservative Jew, to condone Scalise's comment. But he won't; he's too much a coward and always puts his party (well, and Britney Spears concerts, apparently) ahead of everything. Even his religious principles.

user-pic

No, it does not.

user-pic

The comparison I think of is, if your're in a lifeboat with another person, it's not OK to dig holes in the bottom of your half of the boat. It's not OK to set fire to your half of boat. Even if it's only your half.

For that matter, whimsically setting your own house and lawn on fire is frowned upon in most municipalities. Another example of the government stomping on your God-given property rights.

user-pic

It seems like you admit, then, to being a *fascist!* A jack-booted government thug telling me what to do with my own half of the boat! :(

user-pic

Bush arrested at least one American citizen and threw him in solitary confinement, incommunicado, and with no recourse.

That's about as Gestapo as you can get.

user-pic

I think it's insane that the government has so much power over us that we risk prosecution for failing at suicide. Gestapo indeed.

user-pic

Sadly, there are idiots in the world and it seems most of them of GOPers.

user-pic
Scalise: "I don't think the government should be able to tell somebody if they're living in their home and they're abiding by all the laws that they're an unlawful occupant of their house...
Of course, if they're abiding by all the laws, they don't have anything to worry about - isn't that what the Republicans have been telling us about DHS, the Patriot Act, the TSA, etc., for the last 6 years?

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address