TPMDC
« Rosen Defends Article, Backs Off On Sotomayor, Calls Her 'Able Candidate' | Home | Sessions Subordinate: I Thought I'd Be Fired If I Objected To Being Called 'Boy' »

Poll: Specter In (Mostly) Good Shape, Toomey Unelectable

A new Daily Kos/Research 2000 poll finds Sen. Arlen Specter (D-PA) in good overall shape to win re-election in 2010 -- though there just might be an opening for a Democratic primary challenger.

In a Democratic primary against the lesser-known Rep. Joe Sestak, Specter has 56% to Sestak's 11%, and Specter also leads current challenger Joe Torsella by 60%-5%. However, a separate question shows that only 37% of Dem primary voters say they would definitely vote for Specter, while 23% would consider someone else, 16% are definitely for someone else, and 24% are undecideds. This would indicate that some of Specter's support is soft, and a challenger could have a plausible (though definitely uphill) chance.

Dem primary respondents were asked whether they would be more or less likely to vote for Specter if they knew he'd voted against President Obama's budget, or the Employee Free Choice Act, or health care. In all cases nearly half of respondents said it would have no effect, and about one-quarter said it would make them less likely to support him. It could be that if Specter were to vote too much against the Obama agenda, a challenger could potentially hammer those issues and shift some of these numbers around.

The bottom line, however, is that Specter is the heavy favorite, and would have to continue to make a lot of mistakes in order to blow it.

The poll also corroborates the general consensus that former Rep. Pat Toomey, whose conservative primary challenge scared Specter into switching parties, is unelectable against Specter -- and even against Democrats people haven't heard of. Specter has a healthy lead of 55%-31%. With Sestak as the Democrat, it's a 37%-32% Dem lead, and Torsella edges Toomey 35%-33%, with greater undecideds because the Dem candidates are less well known than Specter.

Interestingly enough, this poll has a very different Republican primary result than the Public Opinion Strategies (R) survey from two days ago, which had Tom Ridge beating Toomey in a landslide. Instead, this poll gives Toomey a 41%-33% lead. In a general election, this poll also has Specter in a dead heat with Ridge, with 45% for Specter to 44% for Ridge. Of course, this point appears to be moot now that Ridge isn't running.


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Specter has been around PA for 45 years; Sestak is a relatively new comer and has never run statewide. This poll is measuring name ID. Sestak could win that primary easily since most primary voters are liberals who don't care much for Specter.

user-pic

Especially if he doesn't at least try to act like a Democrat.

user-pic

I agree. The Specter-Toomey comparison probably also measures name recognition in large part. I'd expect any Pennsylvanian to recognize "Arlen Specter," but I'd only expect Pennsylvanians who closely follow politics to recognize "Pat Toomey."

user-pic

Sestak is already beating Toomey also. That's with comparable name ID.

I think we can all agree, the more these two get introduced to the people of PA...the more likely it is that Sestak gets to the current Sen. Specter size lead.

user-pic

Whom ever wins the Dem primary will be the next Senator from Pennsylvania.

user-pic

So, Toomey (down 24 points) is unelectable, but Sestak (down 45 points) just might have an opening?

user-pic

I don't think this latest poll is as rosey for Sen. Specter as you portray it to be. Keep in mind Kos's note at the end of his post - Lamont was trailing Lieberman 65-19 around this same time in 2006...Sestak is only behind 56-11.

Not only that, but there were 3 separate questions about "would it change your vote if Specter voted against X"...the three were:

Budget (already voted no)
Employee Free Choice
Health Care

About a quarter of all Democratic voters said it would definitely make them less likely to vote for him on any ONE of those issues. Think about if he votes against ALL of them. Something tells me that number goes up fast in that case.

Is it an uphill battle? Sure. But this is likely closer to a toss-up than some may think. The real test will be if Sestak announces and starts raising his name recognition. Will it drive Specter left? It's very, very likely. I think if Sestak gets in and starts to campaign hard, you'll see Specter drop below that 50% line pretty quick. When he does, he'll bolt left - or Sestak will be able to mount a VERY serious challenge, one that I'd say he has a good chance at pulling off.

That, and Sestak is ALREADY beating Toomey. So it really is, if he can beat Specter - he will probably be the next Sen. from PA.

user-pic

Clearly, the reason Toomey is coming up short in the general election match-ups is that he's not conservative enough.

user-pic

More PA residents are leaning toward Toomey because of Specter leaving the Republican Party and the fact that citizens want less taxes and less Government intruding in their lives. Specter should retire.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address