TPMDC
« Franken Thanks Minnesota -- And Coleman | Home | Al Franken's Victory Speech »

Franken vs. Coleman: Our Top 10 Moments

It's been a strange eight months following the Minnesota elections. Here are 10 of our very favorite moments (post election), care of TPMDC reporter (and Franken-Coleman authority) Eric Kleefeld:

Nov. 5: Franken Says Race "Too Close to Call"
The day after the election, Franken releases a statement vowing that the race is not over. He doesn't know the half of it...

Jan. 6: Coleman Files Lawsuit Contesting Results
Coleman's lawsuit is filed right after the recount is completed, and is filled with contradictions and flimsy legal arguments. Basically, Coleman and his lawyers say the entire election was tainted, and he deserves to win. In Eric's words, his strategy is "overall throw[ing] everything against the wall to see what sticks."

Jan. 29, Feb. 4: Coleman Tries To Get Ballots Counted Despite Forgery
In so many cases we lose count, Coleman's lawyers try to get ballots OK'd despite the fact that the signatures on the ballot applications were forged. One such argument led to this memorable exchange with lead Coleman attorney Joe Friedberg:

Friedberg: In point of fact, even though I did something I wasn't supposed to do with the application, my ballot should still count because my signature is genuine.

Deputy Secretary of State Jim Gelbmann: Not according to the procedures we use to determine whether the signature is genuine.

Friedberg: I don't care about your procedures.

(Franken lawyer calls an objection, is sustained.)

Friedberg: OK, I do care...

Feb. 27: Franken Team Catches Coleman Hiding a Witness
The courtroom devolves into chaos when Franken's lawyers catch Coleman's team havinghidden a witness, a Republican poll worker from Minneapolis, during the discovery phase of the trial. This came after they'd been caught having withheld notes that were made by this same poll worker. Franken then moved to have Coleman's claims of double-counted ballots dropped. The witness's testimony was ultimately kept in the record, but the damage to Team Coleman's credibility was clear.

March 30: Cornyn Says Election Could Take "Years" To Resolve
NRSC John Cornyn promises resistance to any attempt to seat Franken, saying that the litigation could take "years" to sort out. Nice try, John.

April 13: Franken Declares Victory, Quotes Paul Wellstone
After the election contest court rules in Franken's favor, he holds a press conference outside his home, quoting Paul Wellstone, the Minnesota senator and close friend of Franken's who died in 2002. "It's like what Paul Wellstone always said: Politics isn't about winning, it's about improving people's lives." Wellstone's death clearly had a big personal effect on Franken, spurring him to get seriously involved in politics, which ultimately led to this entire hullabaloo.

April, May: Polls Show Minnesotans Want Coleman to Concede
Three polls show that a majority of Minnesota voters -- from 54%, 63% and 70% -- want Coleman to step back and let Franken take the Senate seat.

May 4: Franken: "Why Am I Grumpy? Oh, I Know Why"
An annoyed Franken describes his strange transition process (one in which he can't pay any of his staffers) and admits that, yes, sometimes we all get a little cranky.

June 30: Coleman Concedes. It's Over.
After the Minnesota Supreme Court unanimously rules that Franken legitimately won the election, Coleman holds a (rather classy) press conference in which he finally concedes the race. Minnesota (and TPM HQ) breathes a sigh of relief.

June 30: Franken Accepts Victory
A jubilant Franken holds a press conference to accept victory and thank Coleman, saying "I'm so excited to finally be able to get to work for the people of Minnesota."

Finally indeed, Senator-elect Franken.


13 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

My favorite Coleman moment was on November 5th, the day after the election, when Norm held a presser to proclaim that, were it him, he'd step back because there was too much at stake and it was important to Minnesota to let the healing process begin.

In fact, the 25 second clip is right here on TPMTV:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZppOhCSRyFw

Short-lived and self-serving.

PEACE

user-pic

Yeah, I was a bit disappointed not to find that on the list.

user-pic

And we seriously need to buy Eric a beer! Great job, Eric!

user-pic
user-pic

Ha! Yes, that was definitely a highlight of the recount phase!

user-pic

Sec. of State mark Ritchie addressed that at an election reform forum I moderated last April. He said the canvassing board spent time on that ballot because sometimes real people have names that weird, so they couldn't be sure if it was a write-in vote, which would make it an overvote, or if it was some weird commentary, or an identifying mark which would disqualify it. I think he said they disqualified it because it was either an identifying mark or overvote, either of which is disqualifying.

user-pic

Overvote sounds right to me. Although, I'm surprised that the election board didn't know that the Lizard People were related to the Crab People on South Park.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV5wmDhzgY8

user-pic


As Tom Stoppard said -

"Democracy is not the voting, “it’s the counting.”

user-pic

Actually, I'd like to forget the whole ordeal. Blatant obstructionism mixed with obscure legalese and hypocrisy (see Bush vs. Gore) is a recipe for mind-numbing boredom and blood curdling frustration.
I can't wait to see Franken in the Senate though. I hope he doesn't couch his sense of humor and make a run to the middle. It would be great to see him suck some airtime from the usual talking point vomiting, Republican spokespersons that we're usually bombarded with in the MSM.

user-pic

Now, I want to hear 'Franken sworn in, takes seat in Senate'.

user-pic

My favorite moments were any time Freidberg opened his mouth! This guy was a train wreck from the get-go. Priceless!

I also want to say that theUptake.org did a fantastic job covering this mess.

user-pic

The Uptake lives on volunteers and small donations, and they are desperate for funds. Beyond surviving, they're also hoping to show people in other states how to start their own Uptakes, but they badly need cash. Remember when deciding whether you can afford to help that they're livestreaming of the whole awful process is the single biggest factor defeating conservative attempts to claim the DFL and Franken and Ritchie stole it. The Donate button is in the upper right. Video shot by the reporter kicked out of Coleman's press conference for the crime of being liberal is on the right. http://www.theuptake.org

By the way, I don't work for the Uptake nor have any financial interest beyond having donated.

user-pic

This now places a double edged sword on the Dem Party Senate Caucus regarding cloture vote.

Any Dem Senator who joins the Republicans on a filibuster will have to answer to the country and to the party.

But it also places pressure on the Dem Party to actually find solutions and to implement them.

They now have the power to do so.....period.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio


Latest Videos




Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address