TPMDC
« Spokeswoman: Gore Schiff Is Not Running For House | Home | Obama Admin Continues Health Care Media Blitz »

ABC: House Democrats Bill Costs "$1.5 Billion [sic]"

If only it were that cheap. ABC is now picking up on the claim that the House Democrats' health care reform bill will cost a made-up number.

A couple things stand out here. First, the ABC reporters who wrote the piece--Jonathan Karl, Z. Byron Wolf, and Huma Khan--seem to be basing their article a couple Associated Press pieces which peg the legislation at $1.5 trillion...based on the contention of one anonymous Democratic aide. For whatever reason, the AP isn't relying in this instance on the Congressional Budget Office--or other, on the record House Democrats--which prices the bill at about $1 trillion. That's without taking into account revenue-generating measures.

Second, they're using the word "billion" instead of "trillion"--a three-order-of-magnitude difference notwithstanding all the problems with the number "1.5".

That now makes two news organizations--Time, and ABC--along with Newt Gingrich who have taken this AP number and run with it. How far will it go?


8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Haperin fixed at The Page. It now says 1 trillion. Keep it up, Brian.

user-pic

You missed all the morning shows yesterday. Today, Good morning America, and I'm guessing Morning Joe has parroted this value. I don't know for sure about Morning Joe but considering how Joe is a mouthpiece of misinformation it's a safe bet.

user-pic

Harry Smith on the CBS Early Show this morning led off with "$1.5 trillion". To his credit, I believe it was Bill Plante who then used the correct number.

user-pic

Reality vs. A.P.

Good vs. evil.

Good always prevails.

user-pic

True, but there's a temporal factor involved. I want Good to prevail before I start pushing up daisies.

user-pic

Wonder what would happen if Dems ran with the ABC story claiming it would cost $1.5 billion? Think the right wing would push back?

user-pic

The ABC News article actually lists both figures. Later, it states:

On Wednesday, the Senate health committee -- one of five committees in Congress mulling a health care reform bill -- approved one version on a party-line vote of 13-10. House Democrats unveiled their $1.04 trillion, 10-year plan for health care reform Tuesday. But it remains to be seen which plan -- if any -- will get passed into law by Congress this year.
user-pic

This is what happens when the media just copy each others homework, instead of actually doing the research.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address