TPMDC
« Snowe Still Opposing Pure Public Option -- Despite Weekend Reports to Contrary | Home | Poll: Louisiana Voters Don't Want Jindal To Run For President, But He Would Carry The State »

Sen. Jim DeMint, The Dems' Health Care Whipping Boy

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) aimed a scathing floor speech this morning at Sen. Jim DeMint (R-SC), who is fast becoming the face of health care opposition for Democrats.

Reid called out DeMint, who said Monday that, "We can give every American access to affordable health insurance plans if we get out of the way and allow the market to work." Here's some of what Reid said today, according to his prepared remarks:

If we sit this one out, as the Senator suggests, more parents will decide they can't take their children to the doctor because it simply costs too much to pay the medical bills, and more small businesses will lay off more of their workers because it simply costs too much to give them health coverage....

'Allowing the market to work' is code for letting the greedy insurance companies - companies that care more about profits than people - continue to deny you coverage because you have a preexisting condition, or you are a certain age, or because you changed jobs.

That's at least the second time Reid has used DeMint's line to frame the health care debate as a fight between Democrats and do-nothing, accept-the-status-quo Republicans.

President Obama himself lashed out at DeMint in a speech on Monday, taking issue with the senator's remark that health care could be Obama's Waterloo. ("If we're able to stop Obama on this, it will be his Waterloo. It will break him," DeMint said.)

In the speech, Obama quoted DeMint and said, "Think about that. This isn't about me. This isn't about politics."

DeMint, though, took that as a compliment.

"I think he played right into my hands," he said yesterday. "Any time the president of the United States goes after a freshman senator, he's losing his grip a little bit."

Check out Reid's full speech after the jump.

"The choices in this health care debate should be about which ideas contain the best solutions to fix a severely broken system.

"The choices in this health care debate should be about how best to lower costs while increasing quality of care and how best to bring security and stability back to health care.

"The choices in this health care debate should be about how to make it easier to stay healthy in America.

"But for some, the choice seems to be whether to act at all. That is a false choice. That is not a choice we have. Not acting is not an option.

"The Republican Leader in the House of Representatives said last month that 'I think we all understand that we've got the best health care system in the world.' Unlike the vast majority of America, he seems pretty content with the status quo.

"And just this week, the junior Senator from South Carolina said that we just need to 'get out of the way and allow the market to work.'

"In other words, he says, let's do nothing. Let's repeat the same mistakes of the past, and dig ourselves deeper into this hole we've inherited.

"That is not responsible. It is not legislating. That approach does nothing to help the millions of Americans who live just one accident, one illness or one pink slip away from losing their health coverage. And that posture certainly does nothing to help the millions of Americans who have no health insurance to begin with.

"If we just get out of the way, as the Senator suggests, health care costs will get higher, and more people who have health care this year will not be able to say the same next year.

"If we let the market work its will, as the Senator suggests, less than a decade from now you will have to spend almost half of your family's income on health care.

"If we sit this one out, as the Senator suggests, more parents will decide they can't take their children to the doctor because it simply costs too much to pay the medical bills, and more small businesses will lay off more of their workers because it simply costs too much to give them health coverage.

"If, as the Senator suggests, we do nothing, we will keep our economy from recovering, keep businesses from growing and keep families from getting the doctor visits and medicine they need to stay healthy.

" 'Allowing the market to work' is code for letting the greedy insurance companies - companies that care more about profits than people - continue to deny you coverage because you have a preexisting condition, or you are a certain age, or because you changed jobs.

"We have already seen what happens when we do nothing. Over the past eight years of inaction, the costs of health care rose to record levels, and the number of Americans who can't afford insurance did the same.

"Right now in Nevada, more than 100,000 people already lack the coverage they need, or have inadequate coverage. We can't afford to treat these people in emergency rooms, which is where the uninsured often go for treatment. And if we don't act, many, many more Nevadans will lose their coverage.

"There are a lot of good ideas about how to fix health care in America at this critical time for our economy's health and our citizens' health. The question is not whether we should explore any of them - our job is to determine which of these paths will lead us back to recovery, prosperity and good health."


9 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I guess Sen Reid thinks this is an effective sound bite??? Come on, Harry you are losing the fight to the repubs and the conservadems because you fail to lead and battle for what the people want!

user-pic

It seems to me Reid is finally hitting back. Besides, he doesn't get to pick which bit the media pick up for a sound bite. I think DeMint handed one to the Democrats. I hope this is Waterloo, only Obama is Wellington.

user-pic

In all honesty, the GOP is no longer an opposition political party. Can this really be true?

user-pic

If we have the best Health-care in the world why haven't the supporters of this current system been out front and outraged by the fact that WHO says that US is not the best in the world and not even in the top ten? If our system is gosh darn good then why are their millions of Americans (both poor and working americans) living in America without health-care? Why do I know at least twenty people who graduated with me from my Master's program who are currently living with no insurance? Our system is not the best in the world and those that spout this non-sense need to step up and show us the facts that back up their rationale for doing nothing.

You know Orin Hatch was on one of the MSM media outlets last night and just kept on reiterating that if Americans thought the government could do health-care then they obviously have not been paying attention. What the fuck? Call this Pol out, let's see some fucking facts! I mean we sent a man to the moon with government support, we defeated the Nazis with government support, we have provided millions of retirees with additional financial support with Social Security, etc. America has done a lot and much of its best actions have come with government taking the lead. How can Orin Hatch be in government if he does not believe in government? Also if our Health-care system is screwed, specifically Medicare then why doesn't Sen Hatch, point out the parts that are failing, why is he not addressing these failures which he clearly sees?

user-pic

Jim DeMint: the gift that keeps on giving. And Dick Morrison agrees with him!

My only concern is that Mark Halperin explained why not to bet against Obama wrt healthcare. Kiss of death, if you ask me.

user-pic
"I think he played right into my hands," he said yesterday. "Any time the president of the United States goes after a freshman senator, he's losing his grip a little bit."

I'm so glad Sen. DeMint can't grasp this. He dropped the pretense that they're concerned for the healthcare of ordinary Americans or concerned about the costs (with no comparison to the costs of an un-reformed system) and finally admitted the truth -- that they're opposing him for purely political reasons. Someone's playing into someone's hands, here, but it's definitely not the president.

user-pic

DEMINT HAS OBAMA RIGHT WHERE HE WANTS HIM!!!

user-pic

Ensign gets a ride from his religio-fraternity brothers to FedEx, then lets his elderly parent's buy off his mistress to the tune of $96,000. Sanford sows his oats on the SC taxpayer's dime, and then shares all the inner details of his emotional life, and how it has helped him to grow. Now we have DeMint fancying himself a foil to President Obama, with a pledge to "break him" over HC reform.

Can someone please just dismiss these guys to recess, so we can get some work done?

user-pic

To be clear, I meant the kind of recess with swingsets, and sandboxes, where these children belong.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address