TPMDC
« New Haven Firefighter Originally Hired By Claiming Discrimination | Home | The Sunday Show Line-Ups »

Neighbor Of Raided Busby Fundraiser: The Call To The Sheriffs Didn't Come From Me!

So who exactly did call in that noise complaint against a fundraiser two weeks ago for Democratic House candidate Francine Busby (CA-50) -- the one that, through a bizarre series of events, culminated in a full-scale raid by the San Diego Sheriff's Department? One of the host's neighbors, it turns out, is very eager to clear her own name and say it wasn't her.

I just spoke with with Jeannie Goodsell, a retiree who lives immediately adjacent to the residence (though the lots are very large -- the houses are over 100 yards apart). The caller is believed by attendees to have been the same person who yelled obscenities and anti-gay slurs at the event -- and Goodsell doesn't want any confusion that this didn't happen from her house.

She said there was no noise at all. "We were home. We didn't even know that the party or whatever it was, the fundraiser, happened behind us," Goodsell told me. "We heard the helicopters that night, but every once in a while helicopters do fly over these orchards, so we didn't think anything about it." She only found out what happened from reporters who came by her home to ask her about it.

"What started bothering us is, it showed up in print that people directly west behind them started harassing them and yelling things about gays," said Goodsell. "We're liberal Democrats -- we have a Buddha on our table."

"We thought our reputation was being ruined," said Goodsell. So she called Francine Busby up, in order to make sure reporters knew the truth. Goodsell was not previously involved with the Busby campaign, beyond being a regular Democratic voter in Busby's previous runs for Congress.

The thing is, Goodsell doesn't really have any idea who made the call, either. Her neighbors on one side aren't the type, she says, and her neighbors on the other side were on vacation at the time -- and they aren't the type, either. If someone had yelled obscenities from her backyard, she inspected the grounds and found no sign of anybody jumping over her fences or otherwise entering.

Goodsell called the Sheriff's Department, as well, and asked them to exonerate her name to reporters. Sure enough, Sheriff's Department Commander of Law Enforcement Services Michael McNally told us that while he cannot disclose who actually made the call -- though it will come out eventually, after the department's internal review of the incident -- he can confirm that the call did not come from the Goodsell residence.


35 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

As you know, a Buddha on the table is a sure sign of a fervent Democrat.

user-pic

Funny. but I think the point was that this neighbor is not a member of the "Christian"-anti-gay-right-wing-nut-brigade.
And I'm happy that the neighbors are eager to separate themselves from homophobes. It would be a good thing if homophobic wing-nuts found themselves increasingly isolated.

user-pic

It is happening slowly but surely. Here in MA, we are now close to 70% in favor of same sex marriage. I actually don't even know anyone who opposes it anymore; except for a couple of authoritarian types at work.

user-pic

Please don't mock someone whose heart is probably in the right place.

The question on the table is not about Mrs. Goodsell's political inclinations, but rather the identity of the person who allegedly phoned in that complaint to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department -- provided, of course, that such a person does in fact exist.

If it's determined that there definitely was a phoned-in complaint which didn't originate at any of the neighbors, then perhaps I'd start by interviewing leaders of the local GOP, to see if any overzealous party member, upon learning about the Democratic fundraiser, might have taken it upon himself to harrass the event in person.

It's standard operating procedure for any law enforcement agency to officially log in any phone call that results in the subsequent dispatch of personnel to a given scene. But if no log exists, then all roads lead directly back to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department.

user-pic

Or a Fred Phelps follower. That's just the kind of stuff they'd do.

user-pic

Exactly, there has to be a way to determine who made the call. All calls to the police are monitored. Let's find out who made the call and expose them for who they are and then maybe tar and feather them (smile)

user-pic

Curiouser and curiouser.

And if it wasn't the neighbors immediately surrounding the property who called, does it make sense that it was someone even further away? The "noise" would have been even less.

This isn't looking particularly good for the Sheriff Department.

user-pic

Someone taking a walk who was "disturbed" by all that questionable activity in the house of known subversive gays.
Maybe walking their dog, and we know how dogs become distressed in the presence of avowed homosexuals. Our black lab, Charlotte, goes into a decline every time our lesbian daughter comes home from college....

user-pic

I think that would be a walk through Ms. Goodsell's or another neighbor's backyard bushes. Maybe someone's houseguest? More likely a dedicated stalker-type busy-body.

user-pic

or some nut keeping tabs on Democratic events to cause a ruckus. Hmmmm, were there any people stalking around from the future opposition?

user-pic

Michelle Bachmann has been known to hide in the bushes to spy on the gays.

user-pic

HAH!

So someone out walking their homophobic dog gets spooked by all that noise. Noise that only that person and that person's scaredy cat dog can hear, mind you. So that person gets all riled up, calls the police and complains that there's wild crazy stuff happening, and police, rather than verifying that description, go charging in with helicopters, dogs, and one very antsy deputy. The reaction to a noise complaint seems extreme, to put it mildly, so perhaps the caller drastically exagerrated what was going on. So will the caller face charges for that?


user-pic

Wow, I would love to hear that excuse IRL. "Look, it's not me that's homophobic-- it's my dog."

user-pic

My dog ate my homophobia! And then he threw up. Because he's a good dog.

user-pic

Kids, kids...

You are all laboring under the assumption that there was a "caller" to the Sheriff's Department.

How do you know this to be a fact? Because the Sheriff's Department said there had been one? Conveniently enough, we cannot know the identity of that "caller", because the cops "cannot disclose who actualy made the call". A cynic might say they're working on inventing one, as we speak, but far be it from me..!

However... also, conveniently enough... the Sheriff's Department was poised and ready for this mystery noise complaint, with the dogs, the helicopters and the nukes. Now, isn't that a well-prepared law enforcement agency?

And finally, if that woman neighbor had not spoken up, someone would have gotten a bonus takedown with all this scandal: the liberal residents of the area. Now, if we could just figure out who...

user-pic

Exactly. The whole thing was set up ahead of time. Either by a homophobic, wingnut repug Sheriff's office, or by local wingnut politicos who got their buds in the Sheriff's office to do it.

No caller, no noise, no criminal behavior by anyone not employed by the Sheriff's Department.

user-pic

I think the homeowner/fundraiser reported hearing the shouted epithets. So that seems to be the only "noise" there was. I want to see this "caller" prosecuted for making a false police report, that's what I want.

user-pic

"We're liberal Democrats -- we have a Buddha on our table."

I just love this line.

user-pic

Harrumph! Every time I get up on the table, my people tell me to get down!

user-pic

I guess this is only funny if you already know my cat's name is Buddha...

user-pic

lol. The context helps a lot!

user-pic

I'll say. I was wondering why closetluddite was getting up on tables. . .

user-pic

Not that I haven't done that in the past of course...

user-pic

Because they're there?

user-pic

Well, my cat Annie isn't allowed on tops of tables and counters, and she's a very good girl who instinctively knows not to press that issue, particularly when she has her choice of comfy beds, couches and chairs to lounge upon - not to mention the occasional lap.

Regardless, the phone call to the Sheriff's Dept. didn't come from me, either.

user-pic

And your kitty is adorable!!!

user-pic

OK, so we know it wasn't the people living "directly west" of the hostesses who called in the complaint.
Time for some intrepid reporter to interview the folks living directly east, north and south.

user-pic

I loved the ACLU's assessment of this whole mess. The sheriffs "illegally entered a private home, disrupted lawful political activity, demanded personal information that was not required and used physical force that was unnecessary."

This is North County, with its byzantine Republican political culture and a sheriff's department which until weeks ago was run by "Indian Casino" Kolender, a hardcore partisan of both Bilbray and his predecessor... someone I've always associated with a heavyhanded approach to politically-motivated policing. Until we find out what really happened, I'm open to the possibilty that there was no call or that it came from a passing Deputy's squadcar.

The TV series Veronica Mars, which is set in a barely-masked North County called "Neptune," featured a county run by a corrupt conservative politicians and a brutally incompetent sheriff's department. My favorite quote from that show was "Nothing in Neptune happens by accident."

user-pic

Maybe Goodsell didn't make the call but it is certainly possible that this houseguest (Buddha) was distrubed by parading gay democrats!

user-pic

Back in the '80s, I was involved with the implementation of a system called E911 ( the "E" standing for enhanced). When a call came in, the screen would display both the phone number and the physical location of the call's origin--or "unknown" if it was a cellular call.

I imagine that E911 technology has made quantum leaps since then, with hard drives replacing magnetic tape for recording calls, GPS for locating callers' locations, etc. It will be very difficult for the Sheriff's Office to cover up any internal hanky panky without attracting a whole bunch of unwanted attention.

user-pic

Do we know that the call didn't actually come from a cell? hehe...

user-pic

The other thing that's a bit troubling about this is the language used in the police complaint cited in flashreport (assuming flashreport didn't make up the report):

"On 6/27/09, at about 2112 hours, Deputy ***** and *****, Clinician ***** responded to 1366 Rubenstein Avenue, Cardiff, Calif, regarding a Loud Democratic Rally with Loud Speakers. The reporting party's residence is located on Summit Avenue just west of 1366 Rubenstein Avenue. The reporting party told dispatchers he was willing to sign and wanted deputy contact. It was later learned that the rally was a fundraiser for Francine Busby who is running for Congress."

Summit is west of Rubenstein. There is no outlet from Summit to Rubenstein and the only way to get from one to the other would be to go either a quarter mile north to Santa Fe and then back south (a trip of about a mile) or a quarter mile south to Westminster and back north (also about a mile). How many people can tell the police the exact address of a stranger who lives in a house whose back faces their back diagonally, across over a hundred yards of orchards, behind them when there's no outlet or access for over a mile?

Also, according to GoogleEarth there are only two homes on Summit that share a property line with the Barman residence - the Goodsell's and the neighbor to the north, who Goodsell exonerated. This means that the call had to have been made by somebody on a non-contiguous parcel at least two parcels removed from Goodsell in either direction, which would've meant distances of 600 and 700 heavily wooded feet respectively (northwest and southwest) before we get to any structure. I see almost no way that one could've made out that this was a "Democratic rally" just from auditory information alone at that distance and under those circumstances, so they had to have known in advance from some other source and complained not because they heard anything but because they knew it was going to happen (from an advertisement or whatever).

Finally, there's the issue of the heckler. Assuming that the caller and the heckler are the same person and that person lived on Summit, it pretty much could only be one particular parcel, two houses removed from the Goodsells (I won't say which one for obvious reasons), again assuming Goodsell's information on her immediate neighbor to the other side is correct, which, although it does not share a common property line with the Barman residence, maybe within earshot if somebody stands at exactly at the right point (over 400 feet esat of their house, by the way) for the specific purpose of trying to listen-in on the Busby event.

Its all pretty fishy, in my opinion. The most logical scenario is that someone knew there was going to be a rally and called in the complaint for that reason and that reason alone.

user-pic

From looking at Google Maps, it looks like there are three, maybe four houses on Summit Ave whose back yards extend close enough to 1366 Rubenstein that if you went to the back of the lot, you could probably hear something being said over loud speakers at the fundraisers.

I'm quite familiar with this general area, and you can see from the Google satellite view how it's changing from a formerly agricultural area with some small, modest homes into one with McMansions by the score. The fundraiser house is HUGE, not that there's anything wrong with that, but it's starting to make sense that some good ole boy who has lived there forever could get riled up at the rich lesbians who are taking over his neighborhood.

Not GOOD sense, but I can see it happening.

user-pic

"rich lesbians," a new euphemism for "commie, pinko, homos?"
At least the neighbors wouldn't have to worry about any of these carpetbaggers turning into teabaggers (obviously something no respectable lesbian would engage in!).
Our little neighborhood in suburban D.C. has 4 known Republican families. My favorite sight during the 2004 election was the perfectly kept- up, gorgeously gardened house w/ its Kerry sign, directly across from the house that rents out individual rooms to ex-druggies, has had frequent "visits" by police due to shots fired and other unexplained loud noises w/ its large ratty Bush sign.

user-pic

Great investigations into the layout of the neighborhood by Blub and Cal Gal.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address