TPMDC
« Tracking The AP's $1.5 Trillion Figure | Home | The Mark-Up, 07-16-2009 »

Senator-Doctors Spin The Health Care Debate

If you have about a half hour to kill tonight or tomorrow or over the weekend, take a look at this video, produced by Senate Republicans:

Sens. Tom Coburn (R-OK) and John Barrasso (R-WY) are among the Senate's more conservative members. But they're also M.D.s! (You may remember Coburn from TPMMuckraker's reporting on the John Ensign scandal as the conspirator who has pre-emptively refused to testify citing patient-doctor confidentiality.)

Now he's back, with his colleague from Wyoming, using his professional degree to give questionable cover to his political aims. This isn't new to the Republican party. Recall that in 2005, then-Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-TN) said he disagreed with physicians' diagnosis of a vegitative Terri Schiavo, based on videotaped footage he'd viewed in his office. Frist is a heart surgeon.


8 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Just goes to show some doctors have no bedside manners. Think I'll check out my physician's political leanings and only frequent Dems.

Pass healthcare reform NOW!

user-pic

I just spent a considerable amount of time looking at The Lancet, NEJM, and other sources, in an attempt to verify one of the first claims these guys make, that US cancer survival rates are 40% higher than Canada and GB. While the survival rates do appear to be higher here, I haven't found any documentation that they are anywhere close to the figure these two guys cite. The closest I could come was a Washington Times article that referenced two Lancet articles, neither of which substantiate the 40% figure, as well as a bunch of self referential additional Washington Times articles. The 40% number strikes me as the kind of statistic thrown out by a bunch of guys who don't expect to have anyone check their assertions against actual research.

user-pic

I suppose: in order to survive cancer, one must actually be treated for cancer... and our healthcare industry has long since shed the habit of treating cancer patients if they can get away with not treating them.

The studies conducted on this would only include those who had received treatment.

Those who had been unceremoniously dumped from their insurance plans or had otherwise been denied treatment by their insurance providers would not have been included in any published study. I think we can all agree on that.

So: let's have a study on how many U.S. cancer patients hav been denied treatment through the mechanizations of the health care industry. And let's compare our score to that of other industrialized nations. This would be something I'd be interested in seeing.

You had to know from the get-go that these people are making stuff up again. Of course, somebody somewhere will accept these bogus Republican claims as fact... so it has become necessary to make a full-time job of refuting every nutbag argument they come up with (without benefits, of course).

user-pic

Hey, get of Dr. Coburn's back, already. As an ob-gyn AND an ordained minister, he was just advising Douglas Hampton on the scriptural bases for and against male pap tests.

user-pic

I am from Coburn's state, where corporate agriculture is big business. Add to this pious person's sins that defense of the western diet is toxic for humans (read "In Defense of Food" by Pollan). Our diet is based on corporate interest in foods that have long shelf life and can be shipped large distances. We subsidize this diet rather than the produce by local organic farmers, that is known to reduce if not eliminate disease like diabetes, heart disease, immune disorders, etc. Pray that Coburn will hear God tell him to "be not afraid" to go against his monied constituency for the health of his voting constituency.

user-pic

Yeah, because all them docs have got the system in such a great shape already.

The one GP I talk with frequently supports single payer. So there.

user-pic

Let's find out how much money these men have taken from insurance companies, the AMA, the FDA, and pharmaceutical companies. That would influence their votes more than their medical "expertise".

user-pic

I'll just rely on Dr. Dean for advice on health care insurance.

Leave a comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

Josh
Marshall

Bio

Matt
Cooper

Bio

Eric
Kleefeld

Bio

Brian
Beutler

Bio

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address