The second issue of the Michele Bachmann comic book series, produced by some of our friends at the Dump Bachmann blog, is now in print, and like the previous issue it presents a chilling portrait of a right-wing lunatic who has risen up to the highest levels of American government.
However, the presentation of the facts in the second issue deviated from the first issue in a key respect -- that this time around, not all speech balloons from Bachmann are necessarily direct quotes from the woman herself. Paraphrases or new punchlines come in -- and unfortunately, this is not a decision for the better.
Early on, the creators give a lesson on the nature of fiction and fantasy usually explored in comics -- and how in this case, the absurd idea being explored is the real journey of a paranoid right-winger to Congress:
(Click images to enlarge.)
As before, the creators' central complaint is that the mainstream Minnesota media ignored just how loony this person was, with her conspiratorial writings about a socialist agenda in public education, with an aim of opposing the free-enterprise system and instituting full state planning (and this was written when George W. Bush was president):
This page, detailing the absurd things that Bachmann said on the campaign trail in 2006, is a great demonstration of where the creators missed the mark:
Rather than paraphrase Bachmann's various claims of the things that God told her, how about directly quoting her, as they did in the first issue? When it comes to the prophet Bachmann's revelations, the details are the best bits -- her narrative of how God called her to run for Congress, and how she and her husband fasted for three days to make sure God was telling them this. What sort of artistic license can ever improve on this:
"And then in the midst of that calling, God then called me to run for the United States Congress. And I thought, 'what in the world would that be for?' And my husband said, 'You need to do this,' and I wasn't so sure. And we took three days and we fasted and we prayed, and we said, 'Lord is this what You want? Is this Your will?' And after the -- along about the afternoon of day two, He made that calling sure. And it's been now 22 months that I've been running for United States Congress. Who in their right mind would spend two years to run for a job that lasts for two years? You'd have to be absolutely a fool to do that. You are now looking at a fool for Christ. This is a fool for Christ."
Thanks to media inaction and her Republican district, Michele Bachmann got to join the House of Representatives, the illustrious chamber once occupied by such individuals as John Quincy Adams, Davy Crockett and Abraham Lincoln:
The creators return to form later on, in a section that details the history of American right-wing conspiracy theorists, tracing Bachmann's ideological lineage back to the John Birch Society and its modern offshoots such as the Council for National Policy:
Now observe how effective it is when the creators start directly quoting from the moment when Bachmann's manias went fully public -- her infamous interview on Hardball -- and her subsequent public denials that she'd said the things she clearly did say on TV:
The next issue will focus on Bachmann's history of gay-baiting for political gain. Here's hoping the creators don't deviate from the form that made a Bachmann comic so effective -- after all, Bachmann's anti-gay talk is comedy gold without editorial interference.

TPM Stories Now Surging on Digg.com

shooter242
October 12, 2009 6:06 PM
Oh brother. Shall we print relevant comparisons of "divine revelation" in Keith Ellison's religion? I'm sure the Koran has lovely passages about what devotees should do, along the same lines as Bachmann's faith.
Personally, I find Bachmann's efforts at discovering her path less obnoxious than the religiosity of Global whatever fanatics.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
hunter
October 12, 2009 8:38 PM in reply to shooter242
Uh, no. The correct comparison would be if you had quotes from Ellison himself talking about crazy divine-inspiration stuff. We know there's plenty of stuff in the Bible and Koran that would be called schizophrenic today. We're talking about her own schizo stuff.
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Dorn76
October 13, 2009 11:23 AM in reply to shooter242
Yeah, why are they being so mean to that nice crazy lady?
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
johnmccsf
October 12, 2009 6:49 PM
And fetishists like Kleefeld
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
duanes
October 13, 2009 10:58 AM
well i wonder if she is related to bushey,, didnt he see inside the soul of and didnt god talk to him,, must be something there for sure, the bitch scares me, how people can actually elect someone that is so stupid and without a ounce of common sense,,then again look at the republican party,,its sad that party is more important than country,,and that youd let your country be sold, stole, and traded for a little power and a lobby job when your finally voted out,, but then that cant be bachmann cause she doesnt have any friends to lobby,, and someone would have to tell her what it ment,, minnistota you should be ashamed of yourelf,,,,,
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?
Bill Prendergast
October 14, 2009 9:45 AM
Bill Prendergast, the creator of the Bachmann comic here. Thanks to TPM for a thoughtful review.
One correction though. TPM writes:
"Rather than paraphrase Bachmann's various claims of the things that God told her, how about directly quoting her, as they did in the first issue?"
We did! The page that the reviewer posted here for you to see as an example of things we "paraphrased"--doesn't contain paraphrases at all.
Those things that Bachmann is saying in those speech balloons--"And (God) came to me and he sent me a vision showing me who I was going to marry," "And years later He came to me and told me to study tax law", etc.--are NOT paraphrases we made up. They are actual quotes, statements she made publicly prior to her election to Congress.
I can understand Kleefeld's predispostion to believe that we made up this dialogue for Bachmann. But the truth is that we didn't--it's on video, and we cite that in the index. Perhaps this is my fault for not putting quotes around the comments that the reviewer cites. But--yup, she said it--we didn't make it up.
It's true that we sometimes "make up stuff" for the little Bachmann character to say--but that is just interjections like "Did you see what they printed about me?" or "You betcha!"
The controversial and hair-raising statements attributed to her in the comic are *hers,* not ours.
As for the quote the reviewer suggest that we use--we are going to use that--just as she said it--in a future issue specifically covering "Michele and God."
Reply | Flag Abuse
Are you sure this comment violates TPM's Terms of Service?